WW XXXX - The scouring of the Shire, vol.2 - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Kath · 12-01-2007, 06:40 PM

Hmm, this stuff about Rikae looks interesting. I'm certainly more taken with it than the idea that morm is a wolf, which seems a bit forced.

But what I haven't done at all is really look at what's been happening to get it clear in my own head, so you're free to ignore the next couple of lists because really it's for my own benefit!

Votes:
The Might 2 ~ Kath, Might
Lommy 1 ~ Nerwen
morm 4 ~ Valier, Sally, Fea, Menel
Nerwen 7 ~ Rikae, Brinn, Agan, Mac, Greenie, Lommy, Kuru
Valier 2 ~ morm, Volo

The Might voting himself, I don't like it. He saw Rikae do it last game, he knows there are a bunch of players from that game in this one who lynched her and felt bad about having done it based on her odd Day 1 behaviour. He could well be a wolf playing a very bold game.

I'm not keen on morm's reply vote for Valier either. He himself admits it was a bit knee-jerk.

Hmm, the placement of Brinn's vote could be a bit suspicious. morm's on 3 and she votes for the candidate a lot of people are discussing, meaning it's quite likely the rest of the village would follow. Could be a wolf saving a fellow wolf there.

Greenie, why would Nerwen's innocence make Lommy look guilty?

So, what am I thinking?

Guilty:
Greenie
The Might
Brinn
morm

Innocent:
Everyone else (it's a long list!).

There's not much reasoning behind that I know, I'm just trying to get things laid out a bit.

EDIT: Ooh! I thought I accidentally posted this half done earlier but I must have put that ring in instead.

12-01-2007, 06:40 PM	#11
Kath Everlasting Whiteness Join Date: Jan 2004 Location: Perusing the laminated book of dreams Posts: 4,533	Hmm, this stuff about Rikae looks interesting. I'm certainly more taken with it than the idea that morm is a wolf, which seems a bit forced. But what I haven't done at all is really look at what's been happening to get it clear in my own head, so you're free to ignore the next couple of lists because really it's for my own benefit! Votes: The Might 2 ~ Kath, Might Lommy 1 ~ Nerwen morm 4 ~ Valier, Sally, Fea, Menel Nerwen 7 ~ Rikae, Brinn, Agan, Mac, Greenie, Lommy, Kuru Valier 2 ~ morm, Volo The Might voting himself, I don't like it. He saw Rikae do it last game, he knows there are a bunch of players from that game in this one who lynched her and felt bad about having done it based on her odd Day 1 behaviour. He could well be a wolf playing a very bold game. I'm not keen on morm's reply vote for Valier either. He himself admits it was a bit knee-jerk. Hmm, the placement of Brinn's vote could be a bit suspicious. morm's on 3 and she votes for the candidate a lot of people are discussing, meaning it's quite likely the rest of the village would follow. Could be a wolf saving a fellow wolf there. Greenie, why would Nerwen's innocence make Lommy look guilty? So, what am I thinking? Guilty: Greenie The Might Brinn morm Innocent: Everyone else (it's a long list!). There's not much reasoning behind that I know, I'm just trying to get things laid out a bit. EDIT: Ooh! I thought I accidentally posted this half done earlier but I must have put that ring in instead.