WWXXXV: Werewolves among the Wolf-men - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Macalaure · 07-03-2007, 08:32 AM

"As of now, I don't feel anything particularly wrong about Brinniel and I would want Rikae to talk and explain her vote of yesterday before I judge her today.

I took another look at Lhuna and didn't find any solid evidence against her in her words. But there remained a strange feeling. Due to Nogrod's suspicion, I will keep her in slight suspicion myself. I'll be interested what Rikae will have to say about her, who was suspicious of Lhuna yesterday but didn't vote her.

The likeliness of having sleepy wolves make Mith, Izzy and Gil good suspects. As I said, I do not suspect Mith (see beneath). I somehow can't put Izzy into any box and Gil is even more mysterious as usual.

I thought the Guy to be on the innocent side, but his recent words about Mith have me in doubt.

As she has just said (and elsewhere), Mith's behaviour is partly due to events that lie beyond us here. If she was a wolf, wouldn't it be foolish to spend almost her whole effort on declaring Nogrod innocent/gifted? Wouldn't there have been better things to do in the little time she had? Obviously, she didn't vote earlier, let alone build a case with good reason, because she had no clear suspect and no time to build that case that Guy demands. In the end she voted Brinn - without good reason - because she happened to catch her eye in that moment, it seems to me. Yes, she has not presented us any great opinions yet, but this points neither to wolf nor to innocent, but merely to an extensive and acute need for sleep.

Guy's case looks, I'm afraid, like a case built by a wolf against his own better knowledge. My eye is on him again."

07-03-2007, 08:32 AM	#11
Macalaure Fading Fëanorion Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: into the flood again Posts: 2,911	"As of now, I don't feel anything particularly wrong about Brinniel and I would want Rikae to talk and explain her vote of yesterday before I judge her today. I took another look at Lhuna and didn't find any solid evidence against her in her words. But there remained a strange feeling. Due to Nogrod's suspicion, I will keep her in slight suspicion myself. I'll be interested what Rikae will have to say about her, who was suspicious of Lhuna yesterday but didn't vote her. The likeliness of having sleepy wolves make Mith, Izzy and Gil good suspects. As I said, I do not suspect Mith (see beneath). I somehow can't put Izzy into any box and Gil is even more mysterious as usual. I thought the Guy to be on the innocent side, but his recent words about Mith have me in doubt. As she has just said (and elsewhere), Mith's behaviour is partly due to events that lie beyond us here. If she was a wolf, wouldn't it be foolish to spend almost her whole effort on declaring Nogrod innocent/gifted? Wouldn't there have been better things to do in the little time she had? Obviously, she didn't vote earlier, let alone build a case with good reason, because she had no clear suspect and no time to build that case that Guy demands. In the end she voted Brinn - without good reason - because she happened to catch her eye in that moment, it seems to me. Yes, she has not presented us any great opinions yet, but this points neither to wolf nor to innocent, but merely to an extensive and acute need for sleep. Guy's case looks, I'm afraid, like a case built by a wolf against his own better knowledge. My eye is on him again."