Werewolf Four and Thirty: Bloodbath in the Anduin Vale

[The Sixth Wizard]

Unless the assassin doesn't kill every Night.

Wasn't there something like that last game? One that could ranger one night and assassin the next but not both in a row?

Whatever the Priestess of Sauron was, she was not the one to kill people, or that's how I see this.

I think what we have killing us a bear of some sort. She also seemed to know the wolves, with the words 'I have done what I can to help you', which I think would be too much of an advantage if they could both kill. Maybe an evil seer? That seems fit.

Does it seem to anybody else that Thinlo and Volo are having a bit too much fun in all this and that they are the leaders in diverting our attention?

I agree. They do seem to be a couple of cohorts, don't they? They even logged off within three minutes of each other. I suppose you could put that down to them being both in Finland, but still. Don't seem to be suspecting each other at all, not much. Yes, strange.

[Thinlómien]

Originally Posted by The Sixth Wizard

They do seem to be a couple of cohorts, don't they? They even logged off within three minutes of each other. I suppose you could put that down to them being both in Finland, but still. Don't seem to be suspecting each other at all, not much. Yes, strange.

Hmmm... well, Volo's an RL friend of mine, just if you didn't know. (I know that's a bad "excuse", but that might explain something.) As to that comment on logging off, isn't that a bit of grasping at straws, Sixie? And I have suspected Volo, though not very much. Right now I think he's more on the innocent side, but I'll be watching him (like everybody else...).

Originally Posted by Noggie's whole post

[

???

Originally Posted by Aganzir

If we lynch an innocent toDay and the wolves kill two innocents toNight, toMorrow there would be 10 left - five of them wolves. Now I don't know if the wolves could win as separate groups even though the number of them matched the number of the innocents, but I'd rather not take the risk.

I think it would be very unfair to us if they could win together. And Sauce, dealing with that much justice in RL, wouldn't make that unfair a game. (Okay, I'm just hoping... But I still think that would make the game highly unbalanced and I think Sauce would have the sense to see it.)

I find TGWBS is a bit too quick to jump to conclusions on the quiet/loud issue. I mean, I don't think Rune's death necessarily points to silent wolves and Menel's wolvishness to loud ones. Rune wasn't the only one to promote lynching the quiet and Menel sure is able to double-bluff a bit. Now I'm not implying you, TGWBS, are definitely wrong. You could be right. But I just find you too hasty... maybe evilly hasty. (Although, I must say you look quite innocent to me on the whole.)