Luthien: Maia or Elf.

Originally Posted by narfforc

If Luthien had never met Beren, should she have been given the choice of which kindred she belonged to like The Peredhil had?. The main problems are that Melian clothed herself in the flesh of Arda, in the form of an elf. Luthien was born of the body of Elf Melian, but what about her spirit, what was that?

I will go and commune with Mandos. Perhaps he shall reveal it to us.