Werewolf XXX - Tol-in-Elendili - The Isle of the Were-Faithfuls - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Legate of Amon Lanc · 03-02-2007, 02:58 PM

Okay, I dare now to present my hardly-summarized list, but please, bear in mind that "advice is a dangerous gift...", so do not focus on it too much. Also, I made it "on walk", so some thoughts might be strange there.

Brinniel - She seems to me of a quite possibility of being a Faithful, trying to catch something and awake an accusation. I am inclined very much to believe her a Faithful, even the first point to that Hookbill discussion could still have been something.
Durelin - The suspicious on her is that she voted for Mänwe quite early. I do not place much on the arguments about her "Yaying", more people did this (Lommy, for example). Actually, these two seem to be quite alike to me, just Durelin looks little more "Chaaarge!", so I'd call her something between Lommy and Mänwe. But I cannot make any further conclusions right now.
Gil-Galad - In general, his behavior is like: "Comes, says nothing, leaves. Comes, says nothing, votes, leaves." From this, I would deduce three possibilities for him, each as much probable as the other: 1) a totally-out villager, 2) a totally-out Faithful, 3) a very clever Faithful, sitting in the shadows and waiting.
the guy who be short - Whatever he might seem, he brought forth some good thoughts. I don't agree with his&Lalaith's „shortlist“ concept, but otherwise he seems ok to me. Maybe a little bit... you know, narrow-viewed. But someone already pointed here that it is stupid to judge people just based on their different approach to solving problems.
Hookbill the Goomba - even though there are some suspecting him, I take his post about being scared of the game as honest. If it shows he is bluffing, I'm gonna hate him

Kath and Kitanna, at first, I was mistaking one for the another (as well as Mithalwen with Lalaith). Now Kitanna seemed odd to vote for Hookbill "out of thin air". Says he "flies under the radar“, while she is doing that herself. Also, looking back she seemed strange to vote Garin.
Kath is undecipherable for me this far, she seems just using too much strange-system of reasoning to me.
Lalaith - much as above, I don't catch much on her, but do not actually take what complains were against her now from some people.
Mänwe - well, seems he has calmed from Day 1. Possibly he: a) is a villager and he heeded the advice/is a Faithful and realized that it brings too much suspection to act like he did. The fact that he voted for Nogrod on Day 1 might be a move from him to accuse someone innocent (who, as we learned, was really innocent).
Mithalwen - seems strange last day, but I must reconsider everything yet.
Rune Son of Bjarne - I don't see any other serious effort from him but against me, Mänwe and Brinniel; and I believe a Faithful would try more.
The Saucepan Man - posting too much for me. All the accusations against him, although being many, are all based (as well as his entire profile in this game, I think) on the people's knowledge of him from the previous games, which, of course, I do not. Need some trace to identify him further.
Thinlómien - I didn't think she could be a Faithful at first, though, last she is behaving somehow different, more suspicious to me, I'd say perhaps "sneaky", in the last time.

Nothing too much to come upon now. And not much time, so

++Brinniel

EDIT: Cross-posted with everyone since... wait... since somewhere in the first part of page 10?!??!!

03-02-2007, 02:58 PM	#11
Legate of Amon Lanc A Voice That Gainsayeth Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: In that far land beyond the Sea Posts: 7,431	Okay, I dare now to present my hardly-summarized list, but please, bear in mind that "advice is a dangerous gift...", so do not focus on it too much. Also, I made it "on walk", so some thoughts might be strange there. Brinniel - She seems to me of a quite possibility of being a Faithful, trying to catch something and awake an accusation. I am inclined very much to believe her a Faithful, even the first point to that Hookbill discussion could still have been something. Durelin - The suspicious on her is that she voted for Mänwe quite early. I do not place much on the arguments about her "Yaying", more people did this (Lommy, for example). Actually, these two seem to be quite alike to me, just Durelin looks little more "Chaaarge!", so I'd call her something between Lommy and Mänwe. But I cannot make any further conclusions right now. Gil-Galad - In general, his behavior is like: "Comes, says nothing, leaves. Comes, says nothing, votes, leaves." From this, I would deduce three possibilities for him, each as much probable as the other: 1) a totally-out villager, 2) a totally-out Faithful, 3) a very clever Faithful, sitting in the shadows and waiting. the guy who be short - Whatever he might seem, he brought forth some good thoughts. I don't agree with his&Lalaith's „shortlist“ concept, but otherwise he seems ok to me. Maybe a little bit... you know, narrow-viewed. But someone already pointed here that it is stupid to judge people just based on their different approach to solving problems. Hookbill the Goomba - even though there are some suspecting him, I take his post about being scared of the game as honest. If it shows he is bluffing, I'm gonna hate him Kath and Kitanna, at first, I was mistaking one for the another (as well as Mithalwen with Lalaith). Now Kitanna seemed odd to vote for Hookbill "out of thin air". Says he "flies under the radar“, while she is doing that herself. Also, looking back she seemed strange to vote Garin. Kath is undecipherable for me this far, she seems just using too much strange-system of reasoning to me. Lalaith - much as above, I don't catch much on her, but do not actually take what complains were against her now from some people. Mänwe - well, seems he has calmed from Day 1. Possibly he: a) is a villager and he heeded the advice/is a Faithful and realized that it brings too much suspection to act like he did. The fact that he voted for Nogrod on Day 1 might be a move from him to accuse someone innocent (who, as we learned, was really innocent). Mithalwen - seems strange last day, but I must reconsider everything yet. Rune Son of Bjarne - I don't see any other serious effort from him but against me, Mänwe and Brinniel; and I believe a Faithful would try more. The Saucepan Man - posting too much for me. All the accusations against him, although being many, are all based (as well as his entire profile in this game, I think) on the people's knowledge of him from the previous games, which, of course, I do not. Need some trace to identify him further. Thinlómien - I didn't think she could be a Faithful at first, though, last she is behaving somehow different, more suspicious to me, I'd say perhaps "sneaky", in the last time. Nothing too much to come upon now. And not much time, so ++Brinniel EDIT: Cross-posted with everyone since... wait... since somewhere in the first part of page 10?!??!! __________________ "Should the story say 'he ate bread,' the dramatic producer can only show 'a piece of bread' according to his taste or fancy, but the hearer of the story will think of bread in general and picture it in some form of his own." -On Fairy-Stories Last edited by Legate of Amon Lanc; 03-02-2007 at 03:04 PM.