Werewolf XXX - Tol-in-Elendili - The Isle of the Were-Faithfuls

[Thinlómien]

I remember I've argued about this kind of matters with Sauce before... It just seems he never gets my point (or then he's always deliberatedly twisting my words, but why would he, since he's not always guilty).

Originally Posted by Sauce

TGWBS had suggested taking account of the fact that Nogrod and Rikae were known (or almost certain, in Rikae’s case) innocents, and that their thoughts were therefore the only ones (other than our own) we could be sure were untainted. That seems to be an entirely reasonable proposition to me, and yet she voted yesterDay on the basis of it.

I was not agaisnt heeding Nogrod's and Rikae's advice, on the contrary. I was only against them nominating the lynch candidates or people taking their word for the absolute truth.

Originally Posted by SPM

she appears to have accepted that Roa was the Cobbler, yet gave no thought to voting for her.

I did give it thought, but didn't write about it. Mostly because I didn't really ponder about it, but thought it's obviously a better option at this phase to try to lynch a wolf than to lynch a cobbler. There is and has been a major disagreement about this here. I will speak no more of it. It has already taken too much of our concentration away from finding faithfuls. There's no use to speculate about it anymore since there was only one cobbler in this game and she's dead.

Originally Posted by SPAM

No, but I can imagine you indulging in a little stirring ...

And you can't imagine me indulging in a "little stirring" when innocent? Seriously, I was not a faithful indulging in such, neither an innocent indulging in such. I was an innocent pointing out weird things.

Sauce, reading your posts I get the impression that every single vote yesterDay was suspicious in your opinion. You accuse those who voted Roa and those who didn't. While it's good to question and suspect people in werewolf, a total paranoia never helps, especially when it comes from a person who is capable of argumenting the village upside down.

Originally Posted by Roa
Funny. I had just the oppositie impression... and I even think I would have grounds for it based on general Cobblery and some knowledge of the ways Roa works...

Teehee! Freudian slip.

~*~

I find Brinn's points about Rune very reasonable. This kind of eases my suspicions of her.

Originally Posted by Rune

Secondly I find it troublesome to be susupicouse of people meerly because they have differnet and sometimes crazy approaches to finding wolves,

I have nothing against people using their own strategies to find wolves... (Or wait, I do have, but this is not about that anyway... ) Why I'm genrally very against the tactic(s) suggested by TGWBS and Lalaith that I disagree with is that they are not merely crazy individual wolf-spotting tactics, but crazy lynching strategies that concern all of us and need co-operation and thus are far more problematic.

~*~

I have a nagging feeling that I might be suspecting people only/mostly because I disagree with them. It really bothers me. I mean, SPM has striked me as very suspicious toDay and I certainly disagree with him about many matters...

TGWBS might fall to this category too, but I'm not ready to discount his suspiciousness because of our disagreements. I think he acts like a faithful would or what would be wise for a faithful. But he tends to have these strong tactics-suggestions (and I tend to disagree with them), but, like I've said before, usually as an ordo he's more ruthless. He's been uncharacteristically careful and cool-headed... My reason shouts "lynch him!" but in some level my gut-feelings say he might be innocent after all. *sigh* Damn this werewolf.

~*~

I'm very confused about this all. I wish I had a clearer picture about this. My suspicions are in all directions in varying degrees, (but I'm not very confident about any of them).