Werewolf XXX - Tol-in-Elendili - The Isle of the Were-Faithfuls

[the guy who be short]

Mith - That first post seemed very weird to me (and to several others). However, I can accept that anybody can make mistakes. Also, you say the sentence was rhetorical (which I didn't perceive). Most of the rest of what you say seems innocent to me, so I don't believe you're a Faithful. However, on day one you have to suspect whoever you can based on whatever evidence you have. There's sufficient additional information today for me, at least (and I believe I have been your most dedicated attacker) to turn my attention elsewhere.

Nogrod and Rikae - thanks for the (up-and-coming) info on your thoughts on everyone. I'll admit I don't know Roa very well. If people think she's that tricksy, I'll remove her from the meta-analysis and we can just see what Nogrod and Rikae think. I suppose interpretation of Roa's words can go either way - she could be speaking her mind or lying to lead us astray. Perhaps it's better to look at people she's simply avoided mentioning strong feelings about altogether: Glirdan, Brinniel, Gil-Galad, Kath and Mithalwen.

I'm having a look at Lommy next.