The mis-interpretation of dear Gimli

[Mithalwen]

Originally Posted by Elladan and Elrohir

For the record, I have heard the BBC adaptation, and it's outstanding, though parts of it -- such as the Nazgul, the Orcs, and Gollum -- make me cringe.

Ooh could be a quintet for the radio thread then - I have started to prepare and certainly the structuring is something I would like to discuss. Personally I think the radio Gollum is superior so I would like to hear your reasons. The sound effects are the cringe bits forme - Legolas' bow sounds like a flabby elastic band and Gollum is being tortured with an empty stapler