The Problem of Rog - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Findegil · 02-11-2007, 03:30 PM

After a frustating search that didn't brought up what I wanted, I am to pharaphrase what I wanted in quote.

"Rôg" (with a circumflex) was an idea I brought up after reading some parts in Parma Eldalamberon. I argued that it would only be a return to an older name. But the idea did neither suit the fraction that were agianst "Rog" as a name of an Elf of Gondolin nor the fraction that argued that we have no reason good enough to justify the change of the name.

As fare as I am aware of the stand of the discussion - and as the one that is in the moment building the physical body of the text, I try to keep upto date with it - the decision was not to change the name Rog as all.

Respectfully
Findegil

02-11-2007, 03:30 PM	#34
Findegil King's Writer Join Date: Jul 2002 Posts: 1,721	After a frustating search that didn't brought up what I wanted, I am to pharaphrase what I wanted in quote. "Rôg" (with a circumflex) was an idea I brought up after reading some parts in Parma Eldalamberon. I argued that it would only be a return to an older name. But the idea did neither suit the fraction that were agianst "Rog" as a name of an Elf of Gondolin nor the fraction that argued that we have no reason good enough to justify the change of the name. As fare as I am aware of the stand of the discussion - and as the one that is in the moment building the physical body of the text, I try to keep upto date with it - the decision was not to change the name Rog as all. Respectfully Findegil