Sister

[Farael]

Originally Posted by Beleg Cuthalion

I disagree. One "yes" would be dishonest and misleading, since I disagree with the three major aspects of this topic.

Perhaps, but there is no need to answer in such fashion. Really, how would you feel if you bothered to create a new topic and all the answer you got was "no, no and no"? Can't think that'd feel well, so if you don't have anything to add to the discussion (and clearly, there IS a reason why you say no, so might as well explain it rather than just say "no") don't post in a hurtful manner at least!.

I don't see it either, if anything I'd say that Arwen and Eowyn's separation from their respective families shows the power of romantic love over family love... or perhaps the bridging of class-gaps (Faramir being almost a pure descendant from Numenor and Eowyn being from Rohan and Arwen, an elf, with Aragorn, a man).