Mouth of Sauron at Erebor ?

[Rune Son of Bjarne]

Originally Posted by Boromir

I just have to ask this one...why not? The Nazgul we know have hissing sounds like a snake...this messenger's hissed like a snake. Sounds like pretty darn good 'proof' to me. You could argue that that some living messenger hissed like a snake...sure thing, but I think you need to show some reasoning as to who else besides the Nazgul have a hissing voice?

This could never be more than an indication that it might be a Nazgul!

It is very basic. . . women have ears, Aragorn have ears. . .Aragorn is a woman?

I know this is an extreme example, but basicaly it is the same. You cannot tell if it is an Nazgul unless hissing like a snake is a thing only a Nazgul can do.

I know you know this, but you asked and so I have to answer.