Tol-in-Gaurhoth XXV: All Star Crossed With Nowhere to Go

[Valier]

Farael was first to post with his Told you so, Told you so stuff. Ok well this is the thing...Noone knows who the other Werecreatures are except their own Lovers. So you saying you told us so, just to make yourself look good could be completely by accident. Because if you are The Werebear or lover, you very well may have guessed who was Bad, but that does not let you off the hook for being bad yourself.

Next is Mac's post. He conveniently says that we should take a close look at Farael and him, but to remember not to limit ourselves to just them....well duh....It just makes me think that when someone says something like "Oh yeah look at me" They will think people won't because they told them to. (I am obviously a rebel against authority ) Then in his next post Mac, pretty much lets Farael off the hook saying it's his style....I didn't know you knew Farael's style Mac His list of suspects is very weak, nearly everyone on it is kinda suspisious with a little more on me.

I think Kath seems like her normal self and I am inclined to think Lhuna and Rikae innocent as well.
I must say that I am almost convinced that Farael and Mac are the last two if not, then at least one of them is for sures. As I said before, if they turn out not to be, just as I said about Holby, then I will eat my shoe.

I'll be around for a few hours and would like to hear from whoever is around about this.

[Macalaure]

Originally Posted by Valier

Next is Mac's post. He conveniently says that we should take a close look at Farael and him, but to remember not to limit ourselves to just them....well duh....It just makes me think that when someone says something like "Oh yeah look at me" They will think people won't because they told them to. (I am obviously a rebel against authority )

I see your point. Yes, I admit, now that you point it out, that would have made me suspicious of myself if I were you, too. I can only say that I said it in good conscience, but you probably won't believe me and I don't blame you for it.

Then in his next post Mac, pretty much lets Farael off the hook saying it's his style....I didn't know you knew Farael's style Mac

Originally Posted by me

but that is said to be his style.

His list of suspects is very weak, nearly everyone on it is kinda suspisious with a little more on me.

I know it's weak. I'm the person who likes that least. But it is honest and I put down exactly what I thought/felt.


So... her first and third reason I see, her second is due to misunderstanding. I feel better about Valier because of it now. I hope Durelin shows up soon.

[Rikae]

Originally Posted by Valier

Farael was first to post with his Told you so, Told you so stuff. Ok well this is the thing...Noone knows who the other Werecreatures are except their own Lovers. So you saying you told us so, just to make yourself look good could be completely by accident. Because if you are The Werebear or lover, you very well may have guessed who was Bad, but that does not let you off the hook for being bad yourself.

True, it doesn't let him off the hook, but I'm not sure I understand how this is really evidence that he is bad. (I suspect him myself, but just playing devil's advocate here). After all, I suspected Morm too, and I would have probably said the same thing if Farael hadn't already.

Next is Mac's post. He conveniently says that we should take a close look at Farael and him, but to remember not to limit ourselves to just them....well duh....It just makes me think that when someone says something like "Oh yeah look at me" They will think people won't because they told them to.

I seem to recall an ordo doing the same thing in a village not too long ago or far away.

I think Kath seems like her normal self and I am inclined to think Lhuna and Rikae innocent as well.

Hmm. This type of blanket "innocent" statement over three people raises alarms for me. I can't say I know what Kath's normal self is like, but she has said some things about Mac that struck me as a tad hasty, considering the evidence.

I must say that I am almost convinced that Farael and Mac are the last two if not, then at least one of them is for sures. As I said before, if they turn out not to be, just as I said about Holby, then I will eat my shoe.

A bit of an "I told you so" of your own, eh?