Greatest Man of Middle-Earth??

[CSteefel]

Originally Posted by Kuruharan

Not so much belittling as trying to put his accomplishments in perspective. Obviously, since some of us don't think he qualifies as the Greatest Man of Middle-earth, it is going to appear like we are being hard on him. That's not really what we are about, but we are trying to get a point across.

Fair enough. I don't necessarily think he is the Greatest Man either, but some of the comments above sound like they are from somebody who has not read the books, or somebody who has some other agenda...