WWJ XII: "Oh the tangled web we weave..." - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Macalaure · 10-14-2006, 02:35 AM

Rune was a thing? I didn't expect that.

Let's have a look.

Day 1

#17+#21
Defends Rikae from me
Announces to look at Lommy
Jokes

#38
Says he'll focus on me and Lommy
Doesn't know what to do with Volo and Jenny
Thinks Rikae innocent
Says Gil is un-Galadish
Won't pay attention to Glirdan yet

#45
Wonders whether we should make up new tactics

#51+#87
There and back again

#90
Criticises Nogrod and will maybe vote for him

#95
Says he has detected a change in Nogrod
Still suspicious of me and Jenny, less so of Volo and Lommy
Votes Nogrod at a time when the votes were still quite spread

Day 2

#131
Doesn't want us to only go for Nogrod, wants us to look at others too
Feels good about Kitanna and her approach, still doesn't know what to make of her cases

#157
Likes the points about the silent people
Tries to decently backpedal with his Nogrod-suspicion

#161
Sees no alternative and votes Nogrod

Difficult to tell whether he already was a thing on Day 1.
His vote for Nogrod isn't safe enough to be a thing-on-thing vote (I'm convinced Nogrod was a thing from the beginning, as I don't think he was the ranger).
He doesn't go for the silent people unlike Nogrod and Folwren.
If Rune only became a thing on Night 2, it would mean he was the ranger, and it would ease my suspicion about Jenny.

Having reread his yesterday's posts, he did put on quite a few signs. The 'I like her approach but don't know what to make with her cases' about Kitanna without any closer examination (this makes me want to have a closer look at them), his telling us to look at others but Nogrod without doing so himself.

Rune was very careful about not putting up signs that point to the other thing. It's possible that Kitanna was right with her suspicion about Menel or Naria, though.

10-14-2006, 02:35 AM	#11
Macalaure Fading Fëanorion Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: into the flood again Posts: 2,911	Rune was a thing? I didn't expect that. Let's have a look. Day 1 #17+#21 Defends Rikae from me Announces to look at Lommy Jokes #38 Says he'll focus on me and Lommy Doesn't know what to do with Volo and Jenny Thinks Rikae innocent Says Gil is un-Galadish Won't pay attention to Glirdan yet #45 Wonders whether we should make up new tactics #51+#87 There and back again #90 Criticises Nogrod and will maybe vote for him #95 Says he has detected a change in Nogrod Still suspicious of me and Jenny, less so of Volo and Lommy Votes Nogrod at a time when the votes were still quite spread Day 2 #131 Doesn't want us to only go for Nogrod, wants us to look at others too Feels good about Kitanna and her approach, still doesn't know what to make of her cases #157 Likes the points about the silent people Tries to decently backpedal with his Nogrod-suspicion #161 Sees no alternative and votes Nogrod Difficult to tell whether he already was a thing on Day 1. His vote for Nogrod isn't safe enough to be a thing-on-thing vote (I'm convinced Nogrod was a thing from the beginning, as I don't think he was the ranger). He doesn't go for the silent people unlike Nogrod and Folwren. If Rune only became a thing on Night 2, it would mean he was the ranger, and it would ease my suspicion about Jenny. Having reread his yesterday's posts, he did put on quite a few signs. The 'I like her approach but don't know what to make with her cases' about Kitanna without any closer examination (this makes me want to have a closer look at them), his telling us to look at others but Nogrod without doing so himself. Rune was very careful about not putting up signs that point to the other thing. It's possible that Kitanna was right with her suspicion about Menel or Naria, though.