Why save them?

[Child of the 7th Age]

Hey, we could start a new poll: "Does LotR have a happy or a sad ending?"

Thinlómien

This is a great question, although I haven't checked to see if there's already a similar thread. I actually think a general thread would work better than a poll. Otherwise people might just "punch the button" and not explain why they felt that way.

If forced to choose, I would vote "yes, but...."