Tol-in-Gaurhoth XXIII: Journey to Hy Brazil - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

the guy who be short · 07-01-2006, 06:29 AM

Going over SpM's analyses from yesterday, I end up feeling more uncomfortable about Kath than either Gurthang or Firefoot, largely on her voting record. She conveniently doesn't vote on Day 1, votes for an innocent Jenny unlikely to be lynched on day 2, clinches morm's death - saving Rune - on day 3, and votes for an innocent Glirdan on Day 4. She often votes for minor candidates with no chance of lynching. On Day 5, She votes for Glirdan, potentially equalising with a wolvish Gurthang, and staring a bandwagon.

Gurthang, meanwhile, consistently votes extremely late. I don't like it. four of his votes have been for innocents, one for a Rune under such suspicion that he would later die anyway.

Firefoot's voting record in less easy to analyse, as she has voted for many who lived yet. Still, it is hardly flattering. The only anomaly is her Rune vote when he was drawing with SpM on Day 4. As SpM says, this my no means exonerates her. It can be construed to make her look bad.

07-01-2006, 06:29 AM	#11
the guy who be short Shadowed Prince Join Date: Jan 2003 Location: Thulcandra Posts: 2,343	Going over SpM's analyses from yesterday, I end up feeling more uncomfortable about Kath than either Gurthang or Firefoot, largely on her voting record. She conveniently doesn't vote on Day 1, votes for an innocent Jenny unlikely to be lynched on day 2, clinches morm's death - saving Rune - on day 3, and votes for an innocent Glirdan on Day 4. She often votes for minor candidates with no chance of lynching. On Day 5, She votes for Glirdan, potentially equalising with a wolvish Gurthang, and staring a bandwagon. Gurthang, meanwhile, consistently votes extremely late. I don't like it. four of his votes have been for innocents, one for a Rune under such suspicion that he would later die anyway. Firefoot's voting record in less easy to analyse, as she has voted for many who lived yet. Still, it is hardly flattering. The only anomaly is her Rune vote when he was drawing with SpM on Day 4. As SpM says, this my no means exonerates her. It can be construed to make her look bad.