Tol-in-Gaurhoth XXIII: Journey to Hy Brazil

[Formendacil]

Originally Posted by JennyHallu

Why did I put blame on Form? Because he deliberately said he thought neither Eomer nor Nilp were guilty, then made the vote that made saving them impossible.

Not saying that I'm blameless... although in my defence I don't recall having a recent voting tally handy when I voted, so other than a vague idea of who the two main victims were, I don't remember knowing the tally at all.

And anyway... just because I didn't think Eomer or Nilp guilty doesn't mean that I didnt' concede the possibility that they might have been. Nilp's one time as a wolf (when he did the whole same spiel) sucked me right in- though I was an observer, that time. Eomer has a track record which should never been ignored, so it seems...

So while I didn't think them guilty, I can't say that I was convinced of their innocence. Whereas I was, and still am, rather sure of Holby's innocence. Not beyond trace of doubt, of course, but more than I was of Eomer or Nilp.

Now, to pass on to things other than defending myself... there are a number of well-reasoned cases out there that intrigue me: Morm's case for Ang, the case for Diamond, the case for Jenny... They can't all be right, surely... but one of them, at least, being right... well, I'd give it good odds.