Elrond doesn't allow Merry and Pippin on the Quest - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Letty · 05-31-2006, 05:57 PM

What if Bilbo had never found the ring?

What if Gandalf found out earlier that it was the One,and it was destroyed earlier, and there was no Fellowship and no War of the Ring?

What if Legolas was gay and in love with Frodo,and killed Sam because he was jealous?

What if Frodo was gay too,and had the same feelings toward Legolas?

What if Aragorn had a crush on Eowyn and decided to marry her instead of Arwen? /Not that I would blame him if he had to choose between Miranda Otto and Liv Taylor/.

What if Boromir had succeeded in taking the Ring from Frodo?

What if Legolas really killed Sam because he was jealous, and no one took the ring after Shelob attacked Frodo,and the orcs took the ring?

What if Gandalf decided to join Sauron and Saruman?

And finally,what if Isildur had destroyed the ring, and there was no book and no movie,and this forum did not exist?

Come on,guys,the what-if scenarios are big fun!

05-31-2006, 05:57 PM	#4
Letty Animated Skeleton Join Date: May 2006 Location: Canada Posts: 48	What if Bilbo had never found the ring? What if Gandalf found out earlier that it was the One,and it was destroyed earlier, and there was no Fellowship and no War of the Ring? What if Legolas was gay and in love with Frodo,and killed Sam because he was jealous? What if Frodo was gay too,and had the same feelings toward Legolas? What if Aragorn had a crush on Eowyn and decided to marry her instead of Arwen? /Not that I would blame him if he had to choose between Miranda Otto and Liv Taylor/. What if Boromir had succeeded in taking the Ring from Frodo? What if Legolas really killed Sam because he was jealous, and no one took the ring after Shelob attacked Frodo,and the orcs took the ring? What if Gandalf decided to join Sauron and Saruman? And finally,what if Isildur had destroyed the ring, and there was no book and no movie,and this forum did not exist? Come on,guys,the what-if scenarios are big fun! __________________ Ash to ash Dust to dust Fade to black I will have my vengeance-in this life or the next