Tol-in-Gaurhoth XXI: Dueling Wizards Werewolf

[Oddwen]

Have to leave for the Day soon. I'm going to put my vote in for

++FEANOR

Of the four doooooom'd, I'm most inclined to think she's evil.

Oh, and

Originally Posted by Morm

I don't quite follow how this could be a hint

Fea's maundering...you like the word, you're the maundering mage, therefore Fea = You, if you're evil she is too...that's what I was thinking.

Good luck all.

[JennyHallu]

I'm checking in...but hubby's sick so I'll be checking out pretty quickly. I tend to agree with the people who think this is a horrendous list for finding an EW...none of these people strike me as that pro-active. Except for Fea, but I don't think she'd make that kind of commitment: I believe her when she says she's over-busy.

And as for the rest:

I know little about Alcarillo. But my initial reaction would be to doubt any wolvishness from him. These suspicions came up first after SPM's death: The deaths, however, are chosen by vote, from wolves who I firmly believe do not know eachother. I might be wrong, but why would the EW tell them who eachother are? As it is, the death of a wolf reveals no tracks to any other, and I think that's why we as a village seem so aimless. We keep looking for the usual relationships and signs, and it makes me so frustrated that I want to pound on my computer screen (bad idea) and scream THE USUAL SIGNS AREN'T THERE!!!! And if the kills are chosen by vote, then Alcarillo's daytime activities with SPM likely have no connection to his nighttime activity. Besides, if I were a wolf, the last thing I would do is kill someone associated with me, and I think Alcarillo is at least that savvy.

Zali looks awful in analysis. I don't like how she always gives herself an out, and is so apologetic. BUT: If she is a wolf, this could be a further argument for my belief that the wolves do not know eachother: If they did, why would she apologize to the village for her sacrifice of Nogrod? She'd know she was going to look good for it in the morning. I will most likely vote Zali.

And finally, I most certainly do not excuse Kitanna from my suspect list because of her sudden helpfulness yesterday. Yes, she went from the same behavior that's got us so worked up about Zali (non-commital apologetics) to long analytical posts, but what did she actually say? I remember no firm conclusions, no flat-out accusations or umm...anti-accusations? Just "well, he could be a wolf, or she could be a wolf..." Kitanna, my dear, excepting Gurthang, any of us could be a wolf. And I don't like that this analysis mode was such a sudden change, and no one else picked up on that. Sudden changes are what I most fear in this game.

So my vote will most likely be Zali, but I am definitely considering Kitanna. Fea really feels innocent to me, and Alc...that's just too obvious, and I think highly unlikely.

[Roa_Aoife]

Originally Posted by Diamond

Oh, and as a “bonus” for all you eager beavers out there, I can already tell you everything that Roa will say about this post. It’ll be a mix of “nonsense,” “clutter,” “in essence, saying nothing,” and “well, duh.”

Diamond, if my analysis of you yesterday upset you, get over it. We're supposed to suspect each other in this game and look for hints that will lead us to the baddies, and that's all I do. "Nonsense" is how I refer to any incharacter posting, in every single game I played. "Clutter" is for ideas and theories that aren't really thought through and just create confusion for anyone else trying to read it. And you did have several posts that stated the obvious and several posts that had lots of words but said nothing at all. If you disagree, then do so, but offer up reasons, not sarcasm. That doesn't help anyone. If you don't like being suspected, don't play the game.

Or are you just mad because I'm on to you?

And your analysis on Fea was interesting, and I'll forgive the lack of depth given the time at which it was done and the fact the Fea has said very little of depth.

Morm's analysis on Zali has me taking another look at her. She does look quite bad in analysis, as Jenny said. I'd like to hear what she has to say for herself though.

And Diamond I believe wanted an analysis on Lal. I'll do that as sson as I get back from church.

[Glirdan]

Hello everyone. I'm just telling you all that I have returned, but only for the time being. I shall be leaving once again in a few days. I provided some services in a village that I visted on my journey and they want me to come back for a Day to help finish what we started. Now, I'm going to go back and look over what's been said for toDay.