Tol-in-Gaurhoth XXI: Dueling Wizards Werewolf

[dancing spawn of ungoliant]

Originally Posted by Fea

I've already explained why I didn't volunteer for the position. I'd die too fast.

Well, as far as I can see you're still alive.


Anyway, out of those who are not on the death list I find Caran quite Wolvish toDay. I noticed that Caran has been a bit apologetic from the beginning (e.g. she apologised to Loki), and she has said quite little about her own suspicions. Sure, she has named suspects and defended some villagers, but her cases certainly aren't verbose. She seems to like talking about the theoretical aspect of Wizard/Wolf hunting much more than actually catching them. She often gives voting stats which is helpful, but tells very little of Caran herself.

ToDay Caran hasn't voiced suspicions at all. She has just defended herself, listed the unknown villagers and said that Di and Roa's initial reluctance to follow "the plan" makes them look less suspicious. Somehow it seems that the whole time Caran has acted more carefully than you'd assume by reading the lorebooks. That carefulness has been pretty apparent especially toDay.

Originally Posted by Caran

Alas, how I have rued my vote from yesterDay... But, as Firefoot said, you win some, you lose some.

An apologizer... *shudders* Seriously though, as Diamond pointed out, this is a bit odd statement. Caran already gave her explanation, but still.

I know this is the blasted "polling the village" and I'll be jumped upon for it, but does anyone have something in their lorebooks about Roa as an innocent?

To me that doesn't look the suspicious kind of "polling", it's just a question. However, that precautious behaviour is something that raises red flags in my mind.

It's not much, just a few things that make me wonder about Caran's allegiance, but looking at the votings and general reputation of people, I think Caran might have been a tempting pick for the EW.


Now, the votes are:

Diamond -> Zali
Jenny -> Valier
Roa -> Valier
Alcarillo -> Roa
Fea -> Roa
Nilp -> Zali
Firefoot -> Zali
Lommy -> Eomer
Gurthang -> Valier
Kath -> Valier (Valier-4, Zali-3, Roa-2, Eomer-1)


More later.