Tol-in-Gaurhoth XXI: Dueling Wizards Werewolf

[Thinlómien]

An OOC announcement: I will be a smaller nuisance for those who can't stand reading several pages every day - I should focus on a school project and an upcoming exam toDay, so I will probably be flooding less...

And if I'm rementioning some things, I'm sorry, but I'm writing this as I'm reading through the thread to get done with this faster (see above^) and I'm too lazy to edit it all...

On Eomer

First of all, I can't quite understand where all these suspicion on him has suddenly sprung from. I don't mean he seems innocent to me (he actually is a neither innocent nor extremely suspicious -case), but I'm rather wary of anyone just making a case out of nothing, though it would be reasonably founded. Anyway, my comments and speculations on the topic:

Originally Posted by mormegil

He also has been using the shield icon rather frequently

I wouldn't think that to be of any significance, morm, since uses it in discussions etc. quite often. Or maybe he has some kind of strategy: if there's no shield, he lies, if there is, he speaks the truth - or something like that. So he could convey messages to his wolves.

Maybe he actually did curse her, if he is the EW... if that's so, I would certainly look to Lommy.

Sorry, Firefoot, but I think that is a bit far-fetched. If he was the EW and I was a wolf, why would he speak truth about other wolves, but not of me? I can't follow your logic...

Originally Posted by Eomer

And, because the wolves do not know each other ...

If he really is the EW, does he tell the truth here?

His vote for Nogrod seemed strange to me even on Day1 as he had not suspected Noggie before. What he himself says on the topic is:

Originally Posted by Eomer

Oh, and Lommy, my vote from nowhere? Um...yeah, it was pretty much a random Day One vote. I could have voted for pretty much anyone. It wasn't as if I was railing against Fea and then changed my vote to Nogrod out of nowhere!

This might point towards he being the EW, or not, but we shouldn't forget this comment...

On other subjects

Originally Posted by mormegil

Oh one other plus about getting Nogrod off, besides being a wolf, it slows down the talk a bit

I hope you're not saying you wish I'm lynched or eaten next...

The people who think I'm suspicious because of trying to be helpful should have a look at Diamond and her Day1 quoting project... Anyway, Di, it was (maybe) useful, or I felt so at least.

Originally Posted by Diamond

The question is, did anyone else make similar posts talking up the importance of the Wolves not knowing each other?

I did, as well. I said they'd be harder to track. If you want to see the post, I think I posted it on Day 1, but that's all I remember.

Spawn has creditable points on Celuien.

I feel Lalaith's very innocent. [QUOTE0Lalaith]As for the changed wolf, there are three possibilities:
...
3. S/he is still among us. If 3, should they come forward?
[/QUOTE] She's the only one raising this topic, and this seems as she's asking advise. You can always question my reasoning here, but I gave it some thought.

I'm too confused about everything to name any suspects except Eomer and Alacrillo (< especially that one) who have nearly all the village after them.

Oh, and that Fea-theory of Eomer's - I think it's only a poor attempt to give the village another EW candidate to think about.... A bit more sound cases would be welcome, though, as I'm not sure about Eomer's guilty, though he seems suspicious.