WWJ VIII ~ Things That Go "Quack" In The Night

[Anguirel]

Originally Posted by Glirdan's revelation post-his proposed scenarios

1) You lynch me toDay and find out that I am in fact the Seer. You lynch spawn and she's proven the Duck. You then lynch Mith and she's provent to be the final Duck. Village win.

2) Same scenario with the exception that Mith is proven innocent or the Goose. There's still one Duck left.

3) You lynch spawn toDay, she's proven guilty. I dream of Mith toNight and (hopefully) shown that she's the final Duck. We lynch her tomorrow. Village win.

4) Same scenario with the exception that Mith is show to me as innocent or the Goose. Dream (not wholly) wasted. I dream a useless dream and get attacked the next Night. Still one Duck left.

I'm being truthful, and I'm sorry if that entails being disagreeable.

In scenario 1, we would not have discovered your Seership on lynching you.

In scenario 2, Mith would not be proven, on being lynched, to be a Goose.

Scenario 3 happened, but, so far as dreaming of Mith goes, you didn't actually dream at all.

In scenario 4, Mith again would not be shown as a Goose.

Your recent comment about dreaming of her seemed to confirm that you hadn't grasped the concept yet. I was trying to help...

Still, if you're really insulted, why don't you leave the village in protest? Seems to be a popular course of action at the moment...

Gentlemen and ladies of our esteemed quorum, I put it to you that what we are dealing with is a very confused Goose. How confused exactly we can't yet tell. I say we find the Duck and then this poor Goose can be given psychiatric help or eaten for Sunday lunch.