WWJ VIII ~ Things That Go "Quack" In The Night

[Mithalwen]

OK I have decided. I guess I am always inclined to expect the law of averages to assert themselves and make SpM guilty. I will hang fire. And he his showing more of hte expected sophistry in his posts I am aware this will look like spite voting - and I would have resisted it for that reason alone save for this post .

How come that someone who has read the rules enough to comment on the goose (and is that really the biggest problem? Surely when someone who has been acting like a duck, turns out not to be a duck when they die, we can probably assume that the goose is dead?) not be able to work out that the Ducks may not PM during the day? Seems to me a question someone would ask to try and suggest that they don't know because they aren't a duck. Therefore I think she is a duck.

++Dancing Spawn of Ungoliant

NB I have just checked before posting - and seen SpM's latest post which I find somewhat reassuring .

I really have to go and have no reason to change my mind. Obviously those who can stay to the end may find reason not to agree with me .

Choose wisely.