Tol-in-Gaurhoth XX: Wereorc I: The elves cannot hide themselves much longer.

[Findëasëa]

I obviously have a lot to think about regarding Nogrod's innocence. My arguments do not have completely certain footing, but I am just trying to be as honest as I can about who I suspect and why. I cede the point that perhaps Nogrod imagined that people would assume that people would not suspect a wereorc to come out and divulge a dream so soon after having suspicion cast upon them. I still maintain, however, that Jenny's list is probably of some significance. Unfortunately I need to leave now and will not come back until after the deadline. If you all really feel that I am a threat to the village, by all means kill me. I am willing to sacrifice so the village will benefit. I just ask that you consider other possibilities before lynching on an innocent.

Although Nogrod is no longer assumed innocent in my theories, Roa still stands out on my list of suspects. My reasoning is that Roa only chose to question me about my assumption of Nogrod's innocence after she herself was called suspicious. It might have been a way to distract from the real issue.
++Roa

[Naria]

My list of suspects and why:

Caran- She is usually fairly insightful and this time she seems not to be. She is all over the place in her accusations and her voting. She gives poor reasons for her votes(yeah, yeah....I'm one to talk, but this is about her now) and she usually does give good reasons. In her post #286 she suspects Nogrod, Kitanna and Roa, but later down the road she abruptly changes her path and votes for me instead of one of the three she mentions on her list. The reason she gave was really bad too, that she didn't know who else to vote for. What?! She had three suspects, all of a sudden it's a mystery on whom to vote for.

Celuien- I was on the fence about her, but kept her on my suspect list because there was something that is gnawing at the back of my neck. She was playing fairly normal, then Sleepy comes out and proclaims her to be the Shaman....she didn't like the idea at first, but now it looks like she is alot more comfortable with it. Maybe she is an Orc using the Shaman proclamation as a cover.

Gren and Fin- Aah, the newbies. They had a rough start, as to be expected, but went on and faced each question head on with very good reasoning. A little too good....and I doubt that we would be so lucky as to have another sibling helping them out in this game . I also doubt that both of them are orcs, One of the above two are probably helping them and that is why Gren and Fin seem to be so helpful.


My innocent list is as follows:

Sleepy- Nogrod dreamt of him

Nogrod- I dreamt of him last Night

Zali- Ranger. Yes she is acting quite weird about it, but I would too if I found myself alive again and again.

Roa- She hasn't done or said anything that has sent any red flags up for me and has been playing as Roa plays.

[Nogrod]

Originally Posted by Naria

Nogrod- I dreamt of him last Night

Well, thanks shaman! And thanks Naria to come up with it! Although this was bad in a sense, that we don't have any new "believable" innocents now. But maybe it is good, that the thing I knew, can be known by you others too...

= Roa
But you still owe us a Devil's Advocate Review on Findeasea. You told us you would yesterDay. Where is it?

I hadn't either the time or the energy to make it yesterDAY. I'll wrap up my RPG-stuff and get on to it (½+ hour). And I have some similar kind of stuff made on Celuien as well (done during the afternoon (GMT)). I'm coming back soon - and will be popping in every now and then, if something happens meanwhile...

EDIT: X-posted with Sleepy