Let's cast the Silmarillion

[Boromir88]

Alan Rickman would actually make a very good
(and crabby) Thingol, sort of like his character
in Galaxy Quest .

And as The Metatron in Dogma...gosh I love Alan Rickman...I can see him as Thingol.

Geoffrey Rush as Morgoth...haha that's good another actor I adore. Or even Brian Cox as Morgoth...he made a really good creepy Agamemnon.

How about Russel Crowe as Ecthelion and Tom Hanks as Earendil?