Tol-in-Gaurhoth XX: Wereorc I: The elves cannot hide themselves much longer.

[Caranlondien]

Caran I find suspicious. She voted for me because other people were suspicious of me, which seems a lot like bandwaggoning to avoid having own opinion. She also thought Sleepy was more substantial than me, and in my view Sleepy was just weird and off the wall, stirring the pot and hardly substantial by anyone's measure of substance. I'd like to know what exactly tipped the scales in that matter.

Diamond, I voted for you before you gave your response defending yourself; and, after reading that response, I do tend to believe you innocent. Also, I didn't base my vote on thinking that Sleepy had posted more substantially than you; I voted for you over him because where he was quiet, you were loud without saying very much at all. I find unhelpful loudness more suspicious than quietness.

Now, I've only just gotten here, so I have to go back and re-read (since I can't trust any of your analyses ) but here are my initial thoughts: As I've already said, Diamond is no longer the forerunner for my suspicion. Nogrod makes some interesting points about Spawn, whom I had previously been inclined to trust. So I think I'll analyze her first. I'm heartened that we're one up on the wolves in the village-kill to orc-kill ratio. Now come on, people, let's kill an orc!

EDIT: left out a word