Relative Powers

[the phantom]

Originally Posted by Thalion

what I think everyone missed in that thread is what does the word "greatest" mean..

Excellent point. Quotes pointing out levels of "greatness" cannot be used directly to determine levels of "power". They are two different words. As The Barrow-Wight said on another thread, according to his dictionary Luthien being the "greatest" means that she was the "largest" of the elves.