Tol-in-Gaurhoth XIX: Ang Sagang Daga, bow.

[littlemanpoet]

What did the dead innocent get right?

Garin: (lynched)

I am not a wolf.

Fat lot of good getting this right got us.
Was inclined to trust Anguirel. (#73)

Anguirel: (killed by werewolves)
Apparently nothing of moment.

Eonwe: (lynched) Huh, he says that casting a random vote on Day 2 with evidence available would indeed be idiotic, and then does so. But he did say before his infamous random vote on Day 2 that he would have a hard time getting on line, which probably meant that he couldn't do the research he intended. He did say he was sorry for randomly voting again. It now looks to me like some werewolves may have taken advantage of his infamous vote and joined the bandwagon against him.

******************

What did the dead innocent say that might be right or wrong?

Garin: (lynched)

#34: thinks Cailín is innocent.

#79: saw abnormalities in Farael's posts.

Anguirel: (killed by werewolves)

# 51: defends Cailín against Samwise's suspicion.

#51:

If TGBWS is a Wolf, then throwing himself into danger could be a strategy to keep Valier out of it. If he's a Lover, it's a quixotic gesture.

#69:

I don't trust the harper [Eomer] who accuses ye one bit

#112: thinks Glirdan's vote was very suspicious.

#118: votes for Glirdan - This may be important as a signal to why he died, though the seeming seer argument seems the stronger. It would not hurt to keep an eye on Glirdan.

Eonwe: (lynched)

He sees the ordo-lover as a cobbler type, and suggests that this person will probably lay low. Maybe, maybe not.

*****************

Who has been suspicious in voting?

Day 1:

Celuien and Glirdan were the middle voters for Garin.
Lalaith, Naria, & Formendacil bandwagoned for Guy, but Formendacil broke the double lynch tie.
Lhuna did a throw-away vote of the innocent Eonwe, leaving a double lynch tie in place.

Day 2:

Cailin, Kath, Lhuna, Valier, & Naria all joined Lalaith's bandwagon against the innocnet Eonwe.
************
Who has potentially shown their innocence by their voting?

Samwise & Caran voted for Lhuna.
************
Who has potentially shown their innocence by sound reasoning and helpful posts?

Caran and tar-ancalime, on on this new Day 3, Cailín, whom I no longer suspect strongly.
*********
Who (not a known innocent) has voted for (now) known innocents?

Day 1
Celuien
Glirdan
Farael
Caran - but voted for Lhuna on Day 2
Samwise - but voted for Lhuna on Day 2

Day 2
Lalaith
Cailín
Kath
Lhuna
Valier
Naria

more to come......