The Breaking of the Hogwarts Fellowship - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Eruanna · 02-24-2006, 05:14 PM

An interesting connection between Frodo and Aragorn, that I had not considered before lmp.
Although this is not meant to be a one to one correlation I do have to say that when I read the first HP book and the description of Harry's scar (which still causes him pain, therefore is never really healed) I immediately thought that Harry was Frodo. There are also, of course, the other similarities already mentioned.
I also have to join with those who believe that Snape will prove to be one of the good guys, in the end.

05-02-2006, 01:14 PM

Here is my theory.

Frodo Baggins = Harry

Samwise Gangee = Ron

Meriadoc 'Merry'Brandybuck = Hermione

Peregrin'Pippin'Took = Neville

Gandalf = Dumbledore

Boromir = Snape ( based on HBP. I know that Snape betrayed dumbledore and killed him, but it is my believe that he did it under force. He also adviced Harry to close his mind. Maybe i am wrong, but i think that Snape might save one of Harry's friends. )

Aragorn= ?

Legolas = ?

Gimli = A gryffindor (
gryffindors and slytherins dont like each other very much)

Sindar elves = centaurs

Mirkwood ( greenwood the great) = Forbidden Forrest

Bilbo = Sirius ( great affection, Both hold a special significance to the two heros. Both are loved like parents

Dúnedain ( rangers of the North ) = Order of the Phoenix

Rangers of Ithlien = Aurors

Sauron[/B] = Voldemord

Mouth of Sauron = Death eater ( Lucious Malfoy)

Ring = horcruxes

Wormtounge = Wormtail

Gollum = kreacher

Deatheaters = Goblins ( orks )

Wargs = Werewolfs

Faramir = Lupin

Eowyn = Tonks

Halbarad = Kingsley Shacklebolt

so what do you say

littlemanpoet · 05-03-2006, 01:52 PM

The correspondences are clear enough at a glance, but on the surface. I wish that you had given descriptions of the correspondences that you see along with the person = person set-up.

02-24-2006, 05:14 PM	#1
Eruanna Memento Mori Join Date: Feb 2003 Location: Past The Point Of No Return Posts: 1,117	An interesting connection between Frodo and Aragorn, that I had not considered before lmp. Although this is not meant to be a one to one correlation I do have to say that when I read the first HP book and the description of Harry's scar (which still causes him pain, therefore is never really healed) I immediately thought that Harry was Frodo. There are also, of course, the other similarities already mentioned. I also have to join with those who believe that Snape will prove to be one of the good guys, in the end. __________________ "Remember, hope is a good thing, maybe the best of things. And no good thing ever dies."

05-02-2006, 01:14 PM	#2
frodoHarrypotter Guest Posts: n/a	Here is my theory. Frodo Baggins = Harry Samwise Gangee = Ron Meriadoc 'Merry'Brandybuck = Hermione Peregrin'Pippin'Took = Neville Gandalf = Dumbledore Boromir = Snape ( based on HBP. I know that Snape betrayed dumbledore and killed him, but it is my believe that he did it under force. He also adviced Harry to close his mind. Maybe i am wrong, but i think that Snape might save one of Harry's friends. ) Aragorn= ? Legolas = ? Gimli = A gryffindor ( gryffindors and slytherins dont like each other very much) Sindar elves = centaurs Mirkwood ( greenwood the great) = Forbidden Forrest Bilbo = Sirius ( great affection, Both hold a special significance to the two heros. Both are loved like parents Dúnedain ( rangers of the North ) = Order of the Phoenix Rangers of Ithlien = Aurors Sauron[/B] = Voldemord Mouth of Sauron = Death eater ( Lucious Malfoy) Ring = horcruxes Wormtounge = Wormtail Gollum = kreacher Deatheaters = Goblins ( orks ) Wargs = Werewolfs Faramir = Lupin Eowyn = Tonks Halbarad = Kingsley Shacklebolt so what do you say

05-03-2006, 01:52 PM	#3
littlemanpoet Itinerant Songster Join Date: Jan 2002 Location: The Edge of Faerie Posts: 7,066	The correspondences are clear enough at a glance, but on the surface. I wish that you had given descriptions of the correspondences that you see along with the person = person set-up.