Tol-in-Gaurhoth XVIII: The Play’s The Thing…

[Boromir88]

As for Boromir...too many of you seem to be treating it as though Boromir was lynched and found innocent. This did not occur. He is still as suspicious as ever in my eyes.

I doubt this will change your mind, but you read too far into the post, but you are sticking to your guns, so that makes me think you are innocent. I don't think a wolf would continue to stick to their same reasoning if most of the village seems to think you are looking too hard at things.

I for once am beginning to watch my own back with the people who are going along saying there's nothing to make from the post you accuse me for. Which I agree them, mind you, but I find buttering up very suspicious. I think one wolf has done so (perhaps Celiuen or Lhuna fit this)

I'm sure he'll understand. I just can't afford to ignore the blighter. Once you take your eyes off Boromir's worthy, solid posts, they won't be drawn back again by lustre of shock till it's too late. I observed that even for Day 1-and like Eomer I don't see why Day 1 shouldn't be a day for discussion like any other-his posts were unusually flimsy.

Oh I understand , that was at a time with not much action and simply random accusations/seer talk, which I feel like not getting involved in. Then the one thing I did think was strange (Lhuna's post) I jumped to, then it was work time so I was unable to attend for the rest of the day and after this post I won't be back until late, probably half an hour before voting again.

I fear this DAY 1 would turn into a 'Lynch him!'-'No, lynch him!' between lmp and Boro that would cost us two innocents and enough confusion for the Werewolves to hide behind in. How about we back off for a while here?~Nilp

I agree, it definitely occurs to me that the wolves can be sitting back laughing at us while two innocents want eachother's heads, but you know my feeling on lmp...He's gotten me to think real hard with his posts, as I don't want to jump into an irrational decision.

lmp's post certainly has me thinking, I want to believe him, but I also never want to be dooped and fooled by a wolf...that's part of the reason for my strong feeling on lmp. Though my suspicions on Lhuna and Celuien are rising, they vote for those who are facing a lot of suspicion today...

20, now infamous as your "as usual" post, you built a theme and variations, to a crescendo of "too usual", instilling fear. I picked up on that: "Why is Boromir trying to subtly create an additional level of fear in regard to these other people? What's his game?" And the you added "this false seer scares me" ... there's that fear again. I wondered why. Perhaps Boro is actually a little scared of this situation. But maybe he's setting something up very subtly. Hmmmm! So I concluded that you were at least as suspicious as anybody else on Day 1, and more than most. As I've said before, once I make a decision, I ride it, maybe too hard. There you have it.

Which you are looking too hard at, like Anguirel...so you lessen in suspicion I'll say, but I'm certainly not willing to just believe you and accept you with open arms as you may send me to a horrible death at night!

For the record I actually buy Anguirel and lmp's suspicions on me. It wasn't my intent to cause any fear, but I can see how it looks like I did. My first post I did talk about the past village of Salem, them infamous werewolf trials in that mud hole. I don't see how that constitutes me as being a wolf, but I definitely see what you mean by me thinking I was trying to establish fear. You are wrong, because it wasn't my intent, but I can see how you get that impression.

I am more worried about those who seem to be going with the lmp/boro/anguirel debaucle-(mormegil, Lhuna, and Aiwendil). What I mean it's as if these have attempted to try and get lmp lynched today.

Mormegil starts out the day with this intricate post of the long suspicion of lmp. As I said I doubt a wolf would take such a strong stance of who to go after, and go right after some one, he did know from yesterday's posts that I would be after lmp and Aiwendil said we should look at those who voted for me. So, he did know their were suspicions established on lmp and perhaps this is his attempt to get everything going against him. But, morm has backed down from his suspicions now after hearing lmp, so I don't think him that suspicious as the other two I will mention.

Lhuna puts me in the innocent category and now votes for lmp, seemingly riding on the suspects of others.

Aiwendil has been doing a clever job of keeping fairly away, yet still seems to be egging it on. He doesn't want to commit fully to accusing lmp, but has done a good job of subtelty saying we should look at him.

Celuien as I think I said above, voted for Garin, who may be starting to get the ball dropping on him as suspicions of Garin have grown.

With all this in mind my suspects (in a jumpled no particular order, but who I will most likely be considering my votes for today...)

Lhuna
lmp
Aiwendil
Celuien

Mormegil I'm still unsure about, and because of that I don't want to rashly lynch him yet, especially since he's good to have around.

Eomer and spawn I am expecting more from our scholarly contributers. And unless I've missed something Farael and Kath too have been really quiet.