WWJ IV: Let the insanity ensue

[Nogrod]

=Nogrod If the situation really is 50-50 (3 against 3), I would hold it a miracle, that it would just be us three innocents discussing here!

=Firefoot I've actually wondered the same thing...

But I wouldn't be surprised to see one or two wolves - timezones allowing - to be here at the very beginning of the day to see that the discussion starts on the "right tracks". I saw you both being quite similar minded about where and how we should proceed?

=Firefoot I'm a little confused by your statement here:
Quote:
Of the seven active writers, three are werewolves.

What is preventing the other two people from being wolves...?

Nothing is preventing it, but ethics maybe.

If someone mails once a day, at quite early hours, and basically says nothing, he is not playing the game. And if he is having a role as a wulf, he is downright cheating, or at least not playing a game with us but sabotaging, or playing games on us. That would be both cowardly and unethical, with all possible standards - and not fun to anyone. So I wouldn't go wasting any bullets on that direction in this tight spot - the WW's won't do that either... And anyhow: to lose a game to a cheater is not a loss. The cheater is the one who loses. The same applies to Elu too, unless he comes bright and active on today.

So rather than keeping on arguing this out, how about we (and Roa) try to cooperate for a while? We're not really getting anywhere this way. Perhaps we should try to look at the other players.

Well, who says were not getting anywhere? I think this has been the best morning we've had.

But by all means, let's look at your list.

I do agree with your conclusions concerning Gandalf, Jenny & Valier. Not enough over anyone to suggest lynching as a first option. But with the same ground, I must disagree with you on Elu and Eonwe: not enough stuff behind any clear accusations.

Elu has been confusing, I admit. He has been confusing up to a limit of not been understandable any more at moments. So I would argue the same as before: wasting of ammunition at this point (if he's a wolf and we lose, we really don't lose: he loses).
Eonwe has been really careful, and one could say, that he could be seen avoiding attention. Well, there are different reasons to avoid attention: one might be a WW, one might be the seer, one might be just that kind of a person. So not enough to suggest a hanging-party to be sent at his door.

About Mithalwen, I'm quite confused. There seems to be nothing wrong in her - and the terrible lynching decision of last night was lighter to carry with her. Just for that reason alone, I would hold my vote from falling over her today. But still, there is some mirkyness in her: too unsuspectable of sorts? Wouldn't open the door for her in the middle of the night...

All this would be so much easier, if people would come out and tell what they think - or what they would like us to believe, they think.

I'll come with some comments on Roa, as I have time to write them out: I have a bit more of them...