Tol-in-Gaurhoth XVII: The Saga Continues to Continue quite Continuously

[The Saucepan Man]

Hurrah! Some more contributions to our debate. But they seem to be coming from the same people each time ...

Interesting how there seems to be a collective suspicion for Kath and Shelob developing - and to a lesser degree, Garin. It is possible that this is the result of Wolfish manipulation against innocents, but there are more people involved in this than Wolfish manipulation alone could account for. And those voicing these suspicions seem to be those that I have little reason to suspect at the moment.

I am thinking in particular of mormegil, dancing spawn and Cailín, all of whom seem to be thinking along the same lines as me as far as Kath and Shelob are concerned. As is malkatoj, who I am now pretty sure is innocent (based on her mistaken vote). Now I doubt that there is more than one Wolf, if any, among this lot. If there is and he or she is responsible for this gathering mood, then he or she is a very skilled manipulator indeed.

I remain slightly suspicious of Glirdan and would like to hear further from him. And I share some of the reservations expressed (particularly by Valier and Cailín) about Garin's behavior. It seemed to me yesterday that he was playing his cards close to his chest (and I said as much), and he certainly has been doing so today.

One point to pick you up on, Cailín:

I just thought that Nilpaurion has a rather easy time this game. He gathered no votes other than his own yesterDay and is still not suspected.

Nilp attracted three votes yesterday (his own, Abercrombie's and Naria's). But, his suicidal tendencies notwithstanding, I see little reason to suspect him at this stage. True, he would act suicidal whether innocent or a Wolf, but that alone is no reason to suspect him. Do you have any other reason for your suspicions?