WWJ III - Nan Qualinmerë: Death Wish Valley

[Mithalwen]

Ang..it was very close ...but it wasn't so much what you said on the last day but the fact we were both there that made me go back and everything made so much more sense with you being the wolf. Especially day one.

No offence intended to less experienced players but it seemed to me that the degree of cool and skill displayed required an experienced player. That pointed to Kath or Ang. Too late for Kath did I realise that Tars comments might have been based on the Thin vote and not the dream but I am comforted that she was cursed so we were better off lynching her. RL pressures meant that I had not been as thorough as I might have been with early posts... so much hot air between innocents it seemed and irrelevant. When on Saturday I decided to look at Valier and Valesse .... Valier did seem more likely.... it seemed unlikely that both would be wolves. I would have expected more distance between them. But Valesses abstention did give me doubts.

Anguirel you do know me very well and for a long time it inspired trust. But then it got too much ... and also the wolf did seem to pick off anyone that I said was innocent except you...... Then at the end ...you were just too confident of my innocence ... an innocent would have surely been more doubtful.

If you had killed Val not Gandalf, I might well have been persuaded... save he was a little too disconnected even for a laid back wolf.

Having left me alive it was the reaction to Thin's lynching and the Garin fiasco that clinched it.... btu it was so close. I really didn't want you to be a werewolf especially after I had believed you innocent all along but ...you were unlucky I had the time to read everything before I decided .... and that I always go tails on coin tosses.......