The "Fair" Sex in LotR

[Naaramare]

Her characterization is therefore not a stock depiction of iconic female on a pedastal. Nice work.

On the subject of Arwen, I've noted that although she may look like Luthien, she acts far more like her maternal grandmother--Galadriel--than she does like her more famous ancestress. Not to say necessarily passive: we have no idea how or whether Arwen served as an aid in power to her father, or a messenger between Rivendell and the Golden Wood (which is an implication that I've come away with) or anything of the sort. For instance, I sincerely doubt that the banner she sent with her brothers and the Rangers was just a banner. I have never believed that Arwen was a passive observer during the War of the Ring; there are many vital roles to be played that aren't on the battlefield.

Witnessing Galadriel's discretion during the War of the Jewels, I find a parallel between her granddaughter and herself.

Whereas if Arwen were to act like the ancestress she resembles . . .well, she'd act like movie!Arwen, wouldn't she? Riding out to her beloved's aid, probably ignoring her father's wishes while she did so, braving battle and fire for him.

Just a thought.

[ July 24, 2002: Message edited by: Naaramare ]