Tol-in-Gaurhoth XV-The Villagers Strike Back! - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Boromir88 · 12-23-2005, 10:00 AM

The thing is if you are Dragluin you cannot be sure of Farael's guilt. I would surely love to put my trust in you Alpha Female, but seeing as you say you are Dragluin, there is no way you can be sure of Farael's guilt. Also, no one's stepped out to refute Farael's claim, so it makes me thinks he is indeed our Hunter. Though I have been fooled in the past.

Farael's action yesterday of going against Meneltarmacil seemed to be based off of that he attacked me for attacking him, then all of a sudden Menel started attacking him. Which either seems like Menel is Sauron or Menel is a hero. Again, I stick to it that what a blunderous slip up it would be if a hero disguising as Carcharoth would "take down" the very person they unsuccessfully killed the night before.

It's pretty clear and evident that the Heroes thought Meneltarmacil was Sauron, and is a noble sacrifice. To be able to pull off a successful Sauron guise like Menel has done, he had to be right about something. Perhaps we should look through his posts to see what there is?

12-23-2005, 10:00 AM	#11
Boromir88 Laconic Loreman Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: USA Posts: 7,521	The thing is if you are Dragluin you cannot be sure of Farael's guilt. I would surely love to put my trust in you Alpha Female, but seeing as you say you are Dragluin, there is no way you can be sure of Farael's guilt. Also, no one's stepped out to refute Farael's claim, so it makes me thinks he is indeed our Hunter. Though I have been fooled in the past. Farael's action yesterday of going against Meneltarmacil seemed to be based off of that he attacked me for attacking him, then all of a sudden Menel started attacking him. Which either seems like Menel is Sauron or Menel is a hero. Again, I stick to it that what a blunderous slip up it would be if a hero disguising as Carcharoth would "take down" the very person they unsuccessfully killed the night before. It's pretty clear and evident that the Heroes thought Meneltarmacil was Sauron, and is a noble sacrifice. To be able to pull off a successful Sauron guise like Menel has done, he had to be right about something. Perhaps we should look through his posts to see what there is? __________________ Fenris Penguin