The Silmarillion Survivor

[The Saucepan Man]

Originally Posted by Lalaith

... but there's a part of me that would quite like to kick off the dreary tie-dye tree-hugger, Yavanna.

But Lalaith, she's female ...

There is an argument for evicting Yavanna, however. Since the Trees were her creation, and the Silmarils are all that remains of their light, she is the most likely to insist upon the return of a Silmaril in return for aid. And that is a condition with which Earendil, in this parallel Silmarillion universe, cannot comply.

So, yes, I would be willing to consider changing my vote to Yavanna ...