Tol-in-Gaurhoth XIII: Enter Shamville

[littlemanpoet]

Okay. Thanks, Wilwa. Please accept my apologies for doubting you, Eonwe.

If Wilwa is lying, which I doubt, then she is a werewof, and one of Firefoot, Anguirel, & Eonwe is a werewolf, the other two innocent and being duped like the rest of us. Just noting that as an "aside" hypothesis.

If Wilwa is the seer, then I must take a good hard look at ...

Glirdan
Kitanna
Lalaith
tar-ancalime

... because I know I'm innocent, and anybody who thinks I'm a wolf has greater respect for what I might do as a werewolf than I do.

Let me just bring one thing to everyone's attention, going back to Day One:

On Day One, werewolves are looking for any chance of any innocent saying something that gives them the chance to cast doubt on that individual. Up until my "elect a leader" post, nobody had done that, and I can imagine that the werewolves must have been pretty frustrated up until then. Immediately after my "eal" post, Glirdan hits me with a ferocious attack. Eonwe provides a reasoned analysis, and my response to these two is (1) reasonable with Eonwe, (2) suspicious of Glirdan. Following this, Glirdan backpedals so fast, he disappears into distance. This, my friends, is the most werewolvish behavior I've seen from anyone at all outside of Wayne. I'll take a closer look now at the rest of those still under suspicion.

[Firefoot]

Celuien? What the devil? What are these werewolves up to? Okay, they couldn't go after the seer, which we have strong evidence is Wilwa, but stronger is needed in a confession from Wilwa as to whom she drempt of last night, and whether that person is werewolf or innocent. And I figured the werewolves would be going after Firefoot or Anguirel.

Yeah... what LMP said. The best thing I can think of is that maybe the wolves are going to try and play suspicion off of Wilwa, Ang, and myself.

There is a fourth option that LMP did not mention, and that is that Wilwa is a wolf and that none of Ang, Eonwe, and myself are wolves, but that is seeming pretty far-fetched right now. Right now, I'm pretty comfortable saying that Wilwa really is the Seer.

So of those remaining, I would say that LMP seems the most innocent to me. I'm not too concerned about Kitanna, either (I could probably be persuaded otherwise, though), which would leave at least one, possibly both, wolves between Glirdan, Lalaith, and tar. For one thing, I highly doubt that all three wolves voted for Wilwa on Day 2, which would mean that either Glirdan and/or tar is a wolf. Glirdan is currently more suspicious to me than tar is. Lalaith is definitely confusing me; I had been pretty sure she was innocent. But I would like to see if we couldn't get some pretty good analyses on these five people today. Could be telling.