TOL-IN-GAURHOTH XII, Erbar Telamarth

[Estelyn Telcontar]

If we go by that 'evidence', tgwbs, then Lhuna is one to keep an eye on as well - she hasn't posted since the game started...

[Estelyn Telcontar]

Tantalizing as LMP's offer of a resting place with wine, chocolate and "other things" is, I prefer my own. And as I cannot guarantee a reappearance by the appointed time, I shall have to cast my vote now. Using the "eeeny, meeny..." 'strategy' I mentioned above, I have chosen:

++Shelob

I can only hope that my random choice was guided, for I have not the wisdom to make a decision with the necessary foresight. Good night!

[the guy who be short]

Hmm, I didn't notice Lhuna's absence. However I'm willing to put that down to time difference - seriously, that girl sleeps so late, it's like she's in another time zone.

[the guy who be short]

Sigh. This will look like bandwaggoning, but hopefully it's for our own good:

++Shelob

[mormegil]

I think it a bit reproachful of out village to want to lynch somebody who hasn't spoken, yet! She still may speak and to lynch somebody based on that piece of "evidence" at this phase is rather spurious. I hope that we are able to at least hear from Shelob before more votes are cast her way.

[Firefoot]

While I completely understand the logic behind it, I'm not sure that voting for Shelob just because she hasn't posted is the best way to go. Granted, she's about as likely as anyone else to be a wolf, but I'd rather vote for someone whom I actually have something to go off of, insubstantial as it may be since it's Day 1. Not that I'm condemning you for it; I just wonder if that's really the best way to go.

Edit: cross-posting with Morm...

[Cailín]

Well, I've finally had the chance to read through all your eloquent discussions and unfortunately had to conclude everyone is being extremely careful or, in Boromir's case, very insulting. No one has confessed yet, though I admit I was only hoping that would happen.

I'm a little wary of Firefoot, because of her general statements, but find many (including myself) guilty of the same thing.

Lhuna and Shelob have been very silent, but I wish not to vote for someone who has not had a chance to defend herself yet.

Estelyn is playing her newbie role well and I believe she should be watched closely, not because I'm suspicious of her yet, but because I know from experience people tend to give newbies an easier time. I just noticed I'm most unwilling to lynch her and that cannot be healthy.

As for the others, I don't know. I shall vote

++EOMER OF THE ROHIRRIM

Reasons? None, really. Habit, perhaps, and he is after all at least slightly evil.

Edit: cross posting with Firefoot and Morm here...

[Formendacil]

And so the whole village is a mass of confusion...

I may have experience sorting out plugged outhouses, but this is beyond any mess-sorting ability that may have given me.

As far as suspicion goes, the closest thing I have to that is Anguirel for opening the voting, and Mormegil for suggesting random voting. Both sound vaguely like Werewolfish ploys to distract people.

Or not. Really, this is an awful mess.

And as far as voting people off randomly goes, I'm all for the anti-LMP bandwaggon. Not because I think him dangerous, or a Werewolf (although there IS a 3/14 chance...), but because his personal life is as foul as my job.

[mormegil]

and Mormegil for suggesting random voting.

I always thought of it a discussion started and it seemed to work.

Now for my suspicions that I spoke of earlier they are of and Cailin and somebody that I still will leave nameless because I want more evidence before I go spouting off. However, with Cailin her post haven't sat right with me. It's a bit unsettling if you take my meaning and her vote for Eomer seems strange because I find him more innocent than most. Though that being said I also find Esty and TGWBS suspicious based on their vote of Shelob. I still have sufficient time to wait but I wanted to get my suspects down on the table now.

[littlemanpoet]

Originally Posted by Formendacil

And as far as voting people off randomly goes, I'm all for the anti-LMP bandwaggon. Not because I think him dangerous, or a Werewolf (although there IS a 3/14 chance...), but because his personal life is as foul as my job.

Well, Formendacil, if you don't think I'm dangerous or a werewolf, then your vote for me is/was (still catching up) no better than Esty's newbie vote for a so far silent one. My personal life is not nearly the threat to the village that three werewolves pose. For shame!

Okay, now for my official Day One suspect list:

Boromir
Mister Underhill
Feanor

Boromir is sounding like a werewolf who, knowing I'm not one, is trying to set me up with a couple other dupes that he and his evil croneys are getting ready to "off".

Mister Underhill is playing way too coy for my liking.

Feanor has been a bit wild after hours, if you take my meaning. Also, the fact that she's picked me to start heaping abuse upon, is not to my liking. If ever someone were to play the werewolf boldly, it would be this Feanor, quite capable of the bluff, double bluff, and bait-and-switch bluff (which I can't even possibly explain but you can bet Feanor would do it).

[Boromir88]

Boromir is sounding like a werewolf who, knowing I'm not one, is trying to set me up with a couple other dupes that he and his evil croneys are getting ready to "off".

Funny barkeep, I can say the same for you right now.

He sees that the village is in a mess, and tries to shift blame onto Fea and lmp for their 'back-and-forth' exchange.

Actually, I think my accusations are a benefit to the village. Or atleast they have been to me, gets me to see how people respond and what not. So, whilst my accusations be totally random, and unlogical, there's a purpose to them, or atleast they serve me a purpose. I hope I don't need to say this in more layman terms.

Again, despite Eomer's vote for me, as of right now he seems fairly innocent. Again foolish for following a foolish person. What is it that's always said, who's more foolish, the fool or the one who follows him? So I guess this makes Eomer more foolish but not a wolf.

Cailin, vote for Eomer just seems totally out of the blue, I guess she did Anguirel's strategy of the straw trick. Which is the dumbest way to vote, but not a wolf.

Anguirel, I've explained, foolish, and a bloody noble, but not a wolf.

Lhuna and Shelob, want to hear from these two. But, right now willing to let them slide, I'm sure there's an explanation for there absense. And think of it this way, if they don't talk tomorrow they're dead anyway.

Estelyn just seems totally lost at this point. This isn't wolfishness, just one getting a grasp of how these wolves roll.

Firefoot and Mr. Underhill I need to hear more from and I would like to before we send them to the gallows.

tgwbs' early vote clears him from a wolf atleast for this day, despite how flawed his strategy is.

lmp, realizing that votes are tied now between myself and Shelob suddenly suspects me, and could probably easily get me hanged since I'm not very well liked here.

Feanor, as I said the gibberish and voluptuous connotation between lmp and herself looks like a ploy designed by the wolves. For if I'm not mistaken the wolves can now PM during the day to discuss strategy?

Formendacil, because of him wanting to hang someone who is "immoral."

With all this being said, I think those who have voted already...
Anguirel
Cailin
Eomer
Estelyn
tgwbs

Are not wolves. With wolves being able to now discuss day and night, I think we can expect them to hange around later and let voting unfold to devise their strategies.

So, I'll probably be on again, but there's a possibility I won't and I'm going to vote for...

++Formendacil

[Boromir88]

I'm not one to advocate lynching a "quiet" one, they would be really stupid wolves, to not be out here molding thoughts and manipulating. And even more stupid would be not to say anything when you're being accused.

I actually think lmp, Fea, and Formendacil are wolves. LMP and Fea because of the endless folderol exchanged between eachother. And Formendacil, because he wants to lynch somebody who's had a less than "moral" way of living. We all have our secrets, mind you that, and three people have the secret of being wolves.

It doesn't matter who's "noble" or who's sick and morally wrong. We aren't here to lynch people who have led an immoral way of living, but to lynch wolves. All the nobility does is trample on the rights of the hoi polloi, there's no use in them if you ask me.

So, lmp, fea, and Formendacil are wolves. Though anyone of you baffoons can be a wolf.

Yes, I take back my accusations on Estelyn. I can't help it her sewing looks so bad a werewolf dun it.

[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

My dear Cailín, your busy schedule does not excuse you from reading carefully. Hsssss, I hiv'nae heard o' sic a heart. By the way, I'm loving this new country. Caught some fine fish this evening in that bonnie loch over yonder. Hmm...

I'll vote for:

++BOROMIR88

He sees that the village is in a mess, and tries to shift blame onto Fea and lmp for their 'back-and-forth' exchange. The posturing of someone who wants to draw wolvish parallels between two villagers whose very roles tie the twain together? Mayhaps.

What? It's the first day! I'm scraping for reasons; we all are.

And help ma hawks but ma heid is hammered. Good night, my loves!

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Originally Posted by Boromir88

LMP and Fea because of the endless folderol exchanged between eachother.

You call my demand of a decent strategy to make up for implying that my honor is somewhat less than, endless? I fear that I must disagree. Though I clouded my request with role-playing teasing, it was given because I've noted that LMP posts frequently, but with little substance, choosing rather to take full advantage of his lecherous role, as opposed to trying to kill wolves. His posts take the attention away from our job... trying to survive. Though he provided us with an organizational tool, that is not any new information to several of us. My own notes chart who mentions whom, and in what light, who is accused, who is defended, who is voted for, what strategy came from whom, and random notes that I find interesting and worth rememberance for each player. All of your accusations, defenses, and random interesting comments have their own special places in my notes. Just because I'm a mere pretty tavern wench doesn't mean that I can't take some pretty darned deep notes.

My two suspects, for little reason besides tweaking my nerves, are B88 and LMP. LMP because of what I've said already, B88 for jumping to conclusions that don't match up.

Originally Posted by LMP

Feanor has been a bit wild after hours, if you take my meaning. Also, the fact that she's picked me to start heaping abuse upon, is not to my liking. If ever someone were to play the werewolf boldly, it would be this Feanor, quite capable of the bluff, double bluff, and bait-and-switch bluff (which I can't even possibly explain but you can bet Feanor would do it).

I'm honored by your opinion of my capabilities, but you're wrong on me. Just because I'm fully capable of pulling off any depth bluff I feel like (most of which include no true work, simply alluding to one and letting your imagination do the work for me) doesn't mean I am. Although at this point, I'm curious about bait-and-switch bluffing, for future use, should the innocents survive (that'a'way we can go help out other plagued villages with our knowledge, you know).

In ANY case... the caps accentuating my sigh... I rather think that the Seer should ought to take a peek at LMP in his/her dreams tonight. Or me. Since my reputation (no, not that sort...) has preceded me, I foresee that I'll never quite be trusted without a Seer saying straight up and honestly to you:

"Fea is pure and innocent as the wind-driven snow, you should stop dropping her name as though it was a rabid ferret, and you should take into account everything she says because she is smarter than you."

I mean... the last part is elaboration, but if you're so confident in my wolvery, you can give me the benefit of the doubt (after all, logic favors me in that I've got a higher likelihood of being innocent than guilty) and have confidence in my skills as an innocent.

Also, Boromir, I'd like to see a potential strategy from you. Though you commented that the village would be severely stupid and deserve a very concisely chopped death should we kill you, you didn't bother saying what we should do instead. At this point, my vote is leaning toward you, Boromir, but I've got a bit of a tug toward LMP as well. You'll note that I don't presume to group pairings of wolves together nearly as often as you do. What are you on now? Three? First you accused Saucie, Lhuna, and Esty. Saucie?! Way to go. Talk about grasping to kill off a complete innocent. And then Lhuna, Esty, and TGWBS. You then immediately drop your suspicion of all three, with no explanation, for another pairing: LMP, Formen, and myself.

I think that the best thing to do is track 'em one wolf at a time. After all, if you try to follow too many roads at once, you'll miss an exit and get lost a half hour from your destination. Haven't y'all ever been on a road trip to know that? Once we pin one wolf, we can track the rest based on that. But throwing out pairings?

Boro, either you've adopted my well-known philosophy, or you're just trying too hard.

EDIT: cross posted with Firefoot, Boro (twice) and morm.

[Boromir88]

I think that one could well be a wolf. It would make sense for the wolves to get one vote early and see how it takes so they don't all have to wait till the end. I find you blanket statement far to encompassing to be true. I don't find you overly suspicious based on this but I simply don't agree with you.~mormegil

I accept this, I'm not stubborn. I can say with confidence though, that I'm not overly suspicious of any of them. But, I agree that there's a possibility, but as of right now I will say none of them are wolves.

Also, Boromir, I'd like to see a potential strategy from you. Though you commented that the village would be severely stupid and deserve a very concisely chopped death should we kill you, you didn't bother saying what we should do instead. At this point, my vote is leaning toward you, Boromir, but I've got a bit of a tug toward LMP as well. You'll note that I don't presume to group pairings of wolves together nearly as often as you do. What are you on now? Three? First you accused Saucie, Lhuna, and Esty. Saucie?! Way to go. Talk about grasping to kill off a complete innocent. And then Lhuna, Esty, and TGWBS. You then immediately drop your suspicion of all three, with no explanation, for another pairing: LMP, Formen, and myself.~Feanor

Probably because you were cross-posting but I explained my strategy...

Actually, I think my accusations are a benefit to the village. Or atleast they have been to me, gets me to see how people respond and what not. So, whilst my accusations be totally random, and unlogical, there's a purpose to them, or atleast they serve me a purpose. I hope I don't need to say this in more layman terms.

What are our two main ways in finding a wolf?

First, the voting, with no voting off the bat this is no help to us. Though it becomes the biggest and best way to find a wolf.

So, what's the other way...talk, and that's what my accusations get do, get people to talk. All the more possibility of them slipping up, and it gets me to see their reaction to my accusations.

Then you accuse lmp of complete hoopla that's done nothing to help us find a wolf, you do the same thing?

And finally...

Boro, either you've adopted my well-known philosophy, or you're just trying too hard.

As much as this may hurt, it's got nothing to do with you.

[Firefoot]

Hm, maybe I am being general, aren't I? Probably because I was trying to respond to seven hours' posting in one post. So here's something hopefully a little more comprehensive:

Anguirel - Starts out with some generalities about the wolves and their probable behaviors. He warns about making generalizations and leaves instructions for the Seer not to reveal his/herself. He wants us to work together. (43) He does some commenting on other people's posting so far, though he doesn't really draw many conclusions as he sets out to do, instead just stating the facts. (50) He defends himself a bit, then issues another warning to the Seer. He also volunteers himself for the noose. (54, 58, 60) He votes Boromir as a random pick from the men. (66, 90) Also, a couple of insubstantial posts not worth commenting on. Anguirel does a lot of commenting on the action, (and what he says tends to make sense, though that isn't necessarily an indicator of innocence) though he seems to have very few personal comments on the people. This is mildly suspicious to me.

Boromir - Points out some people for suspicion, including a mystical person not known in this village - this is interesting, I'm not sure if it might mean anything; a wolf might have already looked closer at the list of villagers than that - likely to generate discussion. (48) He makes some good comments; he expresses his doubt that Ang is guilty despite his vote of him - he's pretty firm on the topic of Esty's guilt - jokingly, I'd think. (69, 70) Recants doubts of Esty, states that he thinks wolvish triumvirite is Fea, lmp, and Formen. (105) He seems to be innocent to me, blundering around in the dark.

Cailin - Generalities. (42) Expresses support of Ang's statements. (45) Expresses desire not to vote for Lhuna or Shelob, also feels doubtful of myself and Esty. (102) There's not much to go on for her. She's not said a whole lot; I'm feeling neutral.

Encai - talks about voting system strategies; doesn't want one volunteer to be lynched. Thinks Ang is either innocent or bluffing wolf. (75) I agree with what she said, but there's not enough to go on to make any judgments. I'd like to hear more.

Eomer - Standard opening comments. (47) Thinks he's spotted something of importance, is unspecific. (52) Agrees that seer should stay hidden. (59) Says that whomever he votes for will have irritated him. (79) I'd like to know what he was talking about in 52, but that's his judgment. He's not posted anything really substantial yet, but what he has said is making sense. I'm leaning toward his innocence. After writing this: Votes Boromir, comments that he's scrambling for reasons (107).

Esty - Opening comments. (44) Defends herself against Boromir's accusations. (51) Expresses doubt on who to vote for (81, 93, 96) Votes Shelob based on lack of posting. (97) Obviously she has some doubts not having been in an infected village, and that could be all it is, which is how I am inclined to think. I'd like to hear some more, though obviously that won't happen until tomorrow. I'm not overly suspicious of her.

Fea - She gives some tongue-in-cheek strategy. (74) Comments vaguely, explains vagueness briefly. (92, 95) This could either be Fea being herself or Fea making us think she's being too absurd to be a wolf. I'm equally willing to believe either at this point. She's certainly on my watchlist, but then... she's Fea.

Formendacil - Disagrees with a wholly random lynching, suggests an everyone-abstain system. (61) Disputes Morm's plan. (64) More of the same. (73) Is suspicious of Morm and Ang; says lmp would be a good candidate for random vote. (103) Somehow seems much more vocal than he is, so I'd say that means he's been contributing well. I'm not sure about him; he seems innocent but I'm uncomfortable with some of the things he says. He's definitely on my watchlist.

Lhuna - Unknown.

Lmp - In-character (as bartender) comments, not much pertinence on discussion. (53, 55, 78) Defends himself briefly to me. (57) Discourages Ang from volunteering to vote, advises loudmouthiness to disguise Seer. (77) Expresses disagreement with Morm's plan. (80) Record of support, accusations, etc., unaccompanied by comments. (82) He's somewhat suspicious; he could be a wolf hiding behind his frequent posts and bartenderness. I'm not sure about him. After: official suspect list of Boromir, Fea, and Mr. Underhill. (108)

Mr. Underhill - Doesn't quite understand Morm's plan, asks for clarification. (72) I really can't tell much about him, he's just about as unknown as Lhuna and Shelob. I would like to hear more from him.

Mormegil - Opening comments, doubt on Eomer - to produce discussion, likely. (41) Suggests everyone vote for a random person off the list (49). Thinks he understands Eomer's cryptic post. (56) Supports his plan. (62) Finds Ang's vote odd in that it's not as random as Ang seems to be proposing. (71) Realizes his plan may not be the best, but is glad it generated discussion. (76, 87) Doesn't want to vote off a quiet one. (100) Is suspicious of Cailin, Esty, and TGWBS. (104) Overall he seems innocent to me. He seems to be following his regular plan of generate discussion and evaluate it. His random plan isn't one I'd agree with, but that's the only thing.

Shelob - Unknown

TGWBS - Declares he's not a weredwarf. (67) Dislikes how some haven't spoken, votes for Shelob for that reason (various posts between 80 and 100).

That took long enough! And yes, I did start getting lazy towards the end (i.e., TGWBS, Morm, and LMP, I didn't spend as much time on yours...) But I guess my current list of suspicions is: Fea, Formendacil, and LMP, though I'm entirely open for persuasion.