WWJ I: A New Saga, A New Beginning... Or Is IT!?!?!?

[Gurthang]

I have fifteen minutes left before I will be too busy to post, so this will be short.


First, against Jack.

1. He didn't vote Day 1.
2. Day 2 he voted late for an already doomed wolf. (to ease suspicion)
3. He seemed to jump pretty high when I first accused him.
4. See post #147 for my process of elimination.
5. He seems very against me being OK with dying. A wolf would be a lot more worried about staying alive, which he seems to care an awefully lot about.

Not a whole lot, but I don't have the time.


Now, instructions for tomorrow. Fea and I will most likely be dead. Then you will know I am innocent and hopefully listen to this.

1. Kill malkatoj.
2. Kill Jack.
3. Listen to TORE. He knows what he's doing. I don't hold against him that he's accusing me, because the evidence is pointing right to me.
4. Remember who Fea dreamed about: TOREstel and Hiriel

If I'm lucky, I'll be back to vote just before the Day ends, but I won't trust to my luck; it seems to not be with me in this game. So if I don't see you, then this is goodbye.

[Folwren]

Originally posted by Gurthang:
First, against Jack.

1. He didn't vote Day 1.
2. Day 2 he voted late for an already doomed wolf. (to ease suspicion)
3. He seemed to jump pretty high when I first accused him.
4. See post #147 for my process of elimination.
5. He seems very against me being OK with dying. A wolf would be a lot more worried about staying alive, which he seems to care an awefully lot about.

Not a whole lot, but I don't have the time.

1. Can't deny this, can I? I told you that I didn't want to vote Day 1 long before voting was over.

2. I am going to vote late again today. I prefer voting as late as possible so that I can get all the evidence that people are going to put out. Will you blame me if the chap I happen to get lynched is a wolf? Go-olly.

3. Everything I said when I jumped pretty high was true, wasn't it?

4. Your process of elimination isn't quite as good as TORE's, I've noted. Why excuse Eonwe and Rune when your reasons for letting them go is one of the very reasons you're accusing me?

I think it's safe to say that Rune and Eonwe are innocent, since they voted to put Bergil ahead when the votes were tied.

For cryin' out loud man! When I wrote out my post and gave my vote, I, too, was breaking a vote and putting Bergil ahead! I just happened to cross-post with Eonwe, and look where that's put me!
And you rule out Thin because you say it would be very foolish for a wolf not to vote the first two days. Ha. Well, with your reasoning of 'He didn't vote Day 1' you may as well say 'It's not safe for anyone not to vote the first day.

5. Oh, yes...oh, yes, I do care an awful lot about staying alive, actually. I'm completely honest with you - I have been the entire game - and I won't deny that I'm rather keen on staying alive.

I hope that that will help clear me and not make people suspect me any more. Anyone who thinks this is a rather violent defense of myself may as well just accept it, because this is how I'm always going to defend myself...this game, last game, next game...anytime. Make note of it.

--Jack

[Rune Son of Bjarne]

I thought i would never trust another person in Fwedawick so much, as to let them deside my vote !

But here goes !

++Gurthang

But no fear Gurthang, if you are innocent i for one are planing on doing as you just said.

[Sleepy Ranger]

Its pretty much confirmed now whats what and even if Gurthang turns out to be innocent we still pretty much have things under control. But then again theres always something else that could happen and if it does I know what I'm going to do. Anyway I don't know how much longer I'll be on so I'll cast my vote.

++Gurthang

[Eonwe]

well, good by gurthang. votes stand (im pretty sure, nobody put VOTE in their title ):

Thinlomiel: Gurthang
Malk: Gurthang
Fea: Gurthang
Rune: Gurthang
Sleepy Ranger: Gurthang

five of ten and no double lynches...may you be a wolf gurthang!

[Eonwe]

well, im not gonna be able to get on for a while, and since i guess gurthang is dead, i will cast my token vote.

++Gurthang

[The Only Real Estel]

My vote (in case you hadn't figured it out yet): ++ Gurthang

My reasons: Already stated many times

Now. I will not be around until NIGHT has already fallen. Most likely the wolves will kill our seer, but no matter who they kill - Fea, me, or Hiriel - stick to the plan.

If Gurthang is a wolf we all know to lynch malkatoj next.

If Gurthang is not a wolf - lynch malkatoj anyway. Don't let anyone tell you different, the evidence is way too strong. After that, I suggest that Jack would be the next logical choice but I probably won't be around that long so it'll be up to you all.

Oh, and Fea. You once asked me if I protected you or not. What if I am not the Ranger at all & have just been playing like I was? And what if the Ranger didn't protect you last night? Just something to chew on...

[The Only Real Estel]

Sorry for the double post but some more food for thought:

Perhaps Jack wouldn't be the third wolf if Gurthang is proved innocent (which I hope he won't be). Bergil did say that he thought "no wolves would have voted" - Jack did not vote. That could've been a bluff but I think it unlikely.

I've always thought Eowne to be innocent but she has been somewhat noncommital & her vote for Bergil could have been a bold way to clear her of suspicion...sorry if I'm confusing, but I'm just throwing some thoughts out there.

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Originally Posted by The Only Real Estel

Oh, and Fea. You once asked me if I protected you or not. What if I am not the Ranger at all & have just been playing like I was? And what if the Ranger didn't protect you last night? Just something to chew on...

Come now, TORE. If you aren't the Ranger, than it's pretty damned obvious that I'm not the Seer.