Scene-by-scene?

[The Saucepan Man]

OK, BW's given the thumbs-up, so it can go ahead.

Mister Underhill will make the necessary arrangements for a sub-forum in the Movies forum.

Originally Posted by Tuor in (formerly of) Gondolin

But which would be the reference dvd used, the movie version or extended dvd?

I see no reason why the process should not include the additional scenes. If people are not familiar with them, then it's up to them whether they contribute with regard to those particular scenes. The discussion could then cover the impact on the films of the addition of the extra scenes, ie comparing the films with and without them.