Werewolf IIX - Tra la la lally, here down in the Saga, ha ha!

[Lalaith]

Gurthang my friend, it was a good job you killed me when you did, as not only did it save our Seer for another night - it turned out the internet access at my hotel was fairly limited and I'd have had a hard time participating as fully as I'd have liked.
And LMP, I'm sorry I kept accusing you of being the Cobbler. I was absolutely convinced, it all fitted together so well...but your rant is even funnier, albeit pathos-ridden, now that I know you were telling the truth.
Well played everyone - cigars all round!

[Boromir88]

It was a very well played game to everyone.

Despite your loss Gurthang, I think you played the role well, there just wasn't much you could have done at the end. After Day 1 everyone just really assumed you were in character and were innocent. Well played, but with the nice plan Saucepan came up with, it pretty much assured your loss. Still a well played game.

mormegil, thank you for the compliments.

Well my dreams went like this...The thing is it seemed like anybody I dreamed of that night who was innocent, ended up dying that night, so it never really benefitted me or the village at all...except SpM that is.

Night 1- mormegil, more of just a random pick and my small accusation of him during the day I never saw as progressing much.

Night 2- Saucepan, I too got concerned as I saw him sort of taking control, just wanted to make sure what side he was on. Now, I wish I wouldn't have wasted that night, as I can see he left plenty of clues for his innocence, and the "Lets hunt some bear" that he was definitely the hunter. Well played Mr. SpM

Night 3- Gil-galad, if you notice the following day that was the only time I really made a suspect list. Because I had found Gil-galad that night to be a wolf. Though I did start pinning people down to certain roles towards the end of the game, in the beginning I did not want to list suspects just in case if I would die, because for the first couple days I was not on to anything and did not want to lead people astray. Then I found of Gil-galad's treachery, hence the first time making the suspect list.

Night 4- Wilwarin, sadly she died that night, so again didn't benefit anything.

Night 5- Nonnacedak, tried to save his life as he was going under suspicion, but I didn't want to draw too much attention to me as it could reveal who I was.

Night 6- Durelin, this night I contemplated between Durelin and Gurthang, and wish I chose my second choice. As Durelin was the Cobbler, and Gurthang was the true one we were going for.

Night 7- Meneltarmacil, he was really the most suspicious as again Gurthang managed to just pass through my dream again. He always seemed to sort of slip under, even after I began suspecting him again. Sorry I doubted you Menel.

It's glad to see the village has won, there are a few things I would try to do differently but overall I was pleased with the way I played my first wolf game. I wish I would have went with my earliest suspicions going into night 5 on Gurthang, but decided to choose Durelin, luckily this mistake did not cost the death of the village.

Again, well played to all.

[mormegil]

One thing that I have wanted to know for a while now is why did the wolves kill me? It would be great to hear from the wolves on their thoughts and conversations.

[Laitaine]

Originally Posted by mormegil

One thing that I have wanted to know for a while now is why did the wolves kill me? It would be great to hear from the wolves on their thoughts and conversations.

Ah, now, there was not much strategy involved. My fellow wolves have played games with you in the past and know you to be a clever player. I read through some of them as well and I must say, you have quite a mind! Plus, it seemed you post quite a bit, and outspokenness could be a problem for us wolves. Naturally, we wanted to stop that. You and SpM were the top on our list, but of course, when I was the last wolf, I did not kill SpM because I was sure he was the Hunter.

:-D Hope that cleared things up for you.

[The Only Real Estel]

I was gone for basically all of the game so I only got to scan through it but it looked like a great game to me. It would've been cool to see Gurthang pull it out, but oh well.

Gurthang's last post was entertaining, but my favorite post was probably Oddwen's lmpberry death for lmp. I had to laugh when she mentioned peach cobbler, but the whole death scene was incredible.

[littlemanpoet]

Originally Posted by The Only Real Estel

...my favorite post was probably Oddwen's lmpberry death for lmp. I had to laugh when she mentioned peach cobbler, but the whole death scene was incredible.

I really got a kick out of that one too. Hmmmm.... still owe her a rep on that one....

[Durelin]

Originally Posted by Saucie

Durelin votes for SpM for fitting his own noted likely pattern of Bear behaviour! (This made me chuckle.)

That made my day.

So did the 'foolish girl' remark...

I want to thank everyone again for such a great game and putting up with me and letting me live past the Third Night. Actually, I lived quite a lot longer than I expected. So thanks. Mostly. And a special thank you to Oddwen for my wonderful death.

[Gurthang]

Actually, Lalaith, I misread LMP posts and thought that you were the Seer! When I found that you weren't, I was kinda mad at him; I think that's part of why I chose him next. That was another bad play of mine, I should have taken out the leaders of the village: Saucepan, but maybe Boromir. Those two misled kills probably were the worst choices I made in this game. Aw, well, we all can't have a brain in our heads.

[Gil-Galad]

i would have laughed if SauceMan was a Bear... if he was it would be a perfect cover-up

[wilwarin538]

That was a lot of fun. I wish I could have lived longer.*Gives Gurthang the evil eye * You all played very well.

[Gil-Galad]

Mith and Laitaine chose most of the vilalgers too kill, i chose Mormegil after Mith got lynched just for the fun of it, plus Mormegil has a history of going after me

[Meneltarmacil]

Night 7- Meneltarmacil, he was really the most suspicious as again Gurthang managed to just pass through my dream again. He always seemed to sort of slip under, even after I began suspecting him again. Sorry I doubted you Menel.

That's OK. I'll admit my actions were a little suspicious. I got lured onto the CaptainofDespair bandwagon mainly because of Saucepan's and your posts, and I did vote for people that others suspected, mainly because I had either come to the same conclusions myself (as in the case of Gil-Galad) or others' arguments were convincing enough and I was out of ideas.

[wilwarin538]

Oddwen Moddwen I have a question. What was the point of my dying words?

Originally posted by Moddwen
But all she said was "Tell the Mormegil that Wilwarin is here", and then she died.

Was it purely for my confusion?

[Lalaith]

Dying words of Finduilas....kind of....

[mormegil]

Originally Posted by Gil-Galad

Mith and Laitaine chose most of the vilalgers too kill, i chose Mormegil after Mith got lynched just for the fun of it, plus Mormegil has a history of going after me

So more or less a personal vendetta? Past games have no relection upon whether or not I suspect somebody in the current game. I think this is basically a rule that is unwritten but all adhere to.