Werewolf IIX - Tra la la lally, here down in the Saga, ha ha! - The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum

Firefoot · 08-14-2005, 05:50 AM

Overnight Mithalwen seems to have gathered enough votes that mine doesn't really count, but here's what I think about each person who has gathered votes:

Gurthang - Not very suspicious; I think he was just playing his role.

Mithalwen - I have found her suspicious almost from the start. I'm afraid she isn't a wolf, but I think she could be. She has given more reasons for us to vote for her than anyone else; my only fear in lynching her is that she could be gifted and she hasn't been able to defend herself.

Firefoot - I'm not suspicious of myself.

Meneltarmacil - I'm semi-suspicious of him. His posts have been short and contributed little; he joined the bandwaggon for Mithalwen. He could be a wolf trying to slip in under the radar.

Alcarillo - I've had a niggling suspicion of him from the start for no reason at all. He's saying the right things, and it's probably nothing. Nothing that I'd lynch him for, anyway.

Durelin - Her vote for me was... odd. I don't particularly suspect her, though, as she had to vote early and hadn't had time to gather evidence on anyone.

I think that Morm's list of Samwise, Menel, Boromir, and Alcarillo may have some merit, though I am not very suspicious of Boromir at this point.

++Mithalwen

Even though I hate band-waggoning, I think she may be the most likely suspect that we have at the moment, and her death could be telling.

08-14-2005, 05:50 AM	#24
Firefoot Illusionary Holbytla Join Date: Dec 2003 Posts: 7,547	Overnight Mithalwen seems to have gathered enough votes that mine doesn't really count, but here's what I think about each person who has gathered votes: Gurthang - Not very suspicious; I think he was just playing his role. Mithalwen - I have found her suspicious almost from the start. I'm afraid she isn't a wolf, but I think she could be. She has given more reasons for us to vote for her than anyone else; my only fear in lynching her is that she could be gifted and she hasn't been able to defend herself. Firefoot - I'm not suspicious of myself. Meneltarmacil - I'm semi-suspicious of him. His posts have been short and contributed little; he joined the bandwaggon for Mithalwen. He could be a wolf trying to slip in under the radar. Alcarillo - I've had a niggling suspicion of him from the start for no reason at all. He's saying the right things, and it's probably nothing. Nothing that I'd lynch him for, anyway. Durelin - Her vote for me was... odd. I don't particularly suspect her, though, as she had to vote early and hadn't had time to gather evidence on anyone. I think that Morm's list of Samwise, Menel, Boromir, and Alcarillo may have some merit, though I am not very suspicious of Boromir at this point. ++Mithalwen Even though I hate band-waggoning, I think she may be the most likely suspect that we have at the moment, and her death could be telling.