Luthien & Galadriel

[Gorthaur the Cruel]

Originally Posted by Eomer of the Rohirrim

Could any Catholic (or Christian - not at all sure of the relevant differences) comment on the significance of Galdriel's desire for power? Is it not slightly evil?

Well, I'm Catholic. Galadriel's desire for power isn't neccesarily evil. She wanted to rule a realm at her own will without the tutelage of the Valar. She was after all brilliant in mind. In the LOTR she has a more Marian quality (virgin Mary) & exhibits qualities similar to that of Melian & Varda. She doesn't plan to become the next Dark Lord by desiring the ring. It merely gave her an oppurtunity to enhance & preserve her already existing power (Nenya). Her pride too was a key element of her desire for power but ultimately she passes the test. She wasn't evil, but I'd say she is a tester (if that makes any sense).