This Barrow-Downer's real name is...

[Gurthang]

*gasp*

I think we have a breakthrough on our hands. Allow me to present the case.

Earlier I submitted that Amanaduial the archer was Orlando Bloom.

Originally posted by Gurthang
Orlando Bloom has been haunting the Downs. I've seen hints here and there, and have determined that he is none other than Amanaduial the archer

And just a bit later, Frodo Baggins stated that he thought The Barrow-Wight was Mr. Bloom.

Originally posted by Frodo Baggins
Orlando Bloom is none other than our dear Barrow-Wight himself!

And then Fea said she thought that Amanaduial was Mister Underhill!

Originally posted by Feanor of the Peredhil
AMANADUIAL THE ARCHER -> MI TER UNDERH L AAAAACH

Look at all those letters you have in common. Coincidence? I doubt it. I submit that Archer and Underhillo are one and the same!

Hmmmm...
So if Amanaduial is Orlando Bloom and The Barrow-Wight is also Orlando Bloom and Amanaduial and Mister Underhill are one and the same then...

Amanaduial the archer, Mister Underhill, and The Barrow-Wight are all Orlando Bloom!

All you have to do is put 2 and 4 together, and what do you get...?

Originally posted by Amanaduial the archer
Now the question - what exactly do I have in common with Mr. Underhill and the Barrow-Wight?

Feeling a little conspicuous, aren't we?