Tol-in-Gaurhoth IV (The Saga, erm, Still Continues...)

[Lalaith]

have already said that I think Lalaith is no fool. On the other hand, if she is not a werewolf, she has made some pretty ghastly muffs

Tell me about it. I can't tell you how stupid I feel. I got back an hour before voting, found everyone had been posting like crazy, and I wanted to read carefully before I voted. But not carefully enough, I honestly thought Eomer had four votes, not five, and in a gamble that the missing voter would show, and also wanted to save Eomer, I went for Oddwen. I had already deduced (post 130, sorry don't understand the dark arts of posting single post link) that Eomer was most likely innocent, and I thought he might be the Seer, and so needed to be saved.
Losgulhugwen also voted for Oddwen. (It was a double post - I didn't see her vote until I'd voted myself). Did she (I think it's a she!?) make the same mistake as me? It's quite possible...

As for my vote for Kath, I don't think I should be singled out for that. I don't think anyone made particularly good voting choices that day. Including those that didn't vote at all and left five villagers up for lynching. We know now that two of the other nominees were innocent and a third is quite likely to be innocent. And as for the fourth, phantom just voted for Losgulhugwen because he thought she would die anyway as an absentee.
(Btw Saurreg you forgot Feanor off your list of voters, she voted for Eomer, remember?)
I don't think you can blame me for Kath. But you can blame me all you like for the Oddwen stupidity, and honestly, if it weren't for the fact that it would be highly dangerous at this stage to lose another innocent, I'd offer myself up for lynching just so the village would lose a member who is clearly a liability. I really am sorry... but I am not a werewolf.