Tol-in-Gaurhoth III (The Saga Continues...)

[The Only Real Estel]

Originally posted by Fordim:

1) Sauce is a stupid wolf. This would explain why he is constantly doing things to bring down suspicion on himself and why he narrowly escaped lynching yesterday. The problem I have with this theory is that Sauce is not stupid. I can’t be any more persuasive than that: he just ain’t.

Actually, it takes a very witty person (or wolf) to last as long as Sauce has under as much suspicion as he has endured. I still think he is guilty enough to merit a vote.

Originally posted by Sauce:

One thing that I noticed at the time about Kuru on Day 2 was how very defensive he was. Reading through the day's proceedings again, it is incredible just how defensive he is, notwithstanding that there were only two people who made any kind of serious accusations against him that day. Almost from the outset, his posts had a defensive tone, probably because he realised that people might seek to make something of his role in Evisse's death

But remember what suspecting the last person that we lynched because he was 'to defensive' got us - just a shorter end of the stick to work with. Kuru strikes me as a very blunt character anyway, his defense methods do not suprise me or else I would post that they do, like I did with my reservations about phantom.

At one point, mormegil pretended to waver between voting against me or the phantom

I was somewhat bothered by the fact that mormegil said that he would review evidence, then went ahead & cast his vote for phantom anyway; and without a word towards my argument that phantom should stay or anything. Still, I do not find him nearly as guilty as I find you at the moment.