Tol-in-Gaurhoth III (The Saga Continues...)

[the phantom]

However, there is a simple question I'd like to put before the village (such as it is). Is there anybody here who does not strongly suspect The Saucepan Man? If there isn't, why are we even bothering with this palaver? If there is some consensus on a suspect, shouldn't we act on it? I think that it would be, at the very least, informative.

I agree.

If you go by what people have said and who they have voted for and hold them to it then Kuru, Estel, Fordim, Holby, Shelob, and I should all be willing to cast a vote for SPM, and I may even be forgetting someone. Even if I'm not, that's still the necessary number of votes (six).