Tol-in-Gaurhoth (Isle of Werewolves)

[Feanor of the Peredhil]

From DAY ONE I thought Feanor was a werewolf.

So from day one, you were wrong. Congratulations.

She attacked both Saucepan Man and bilbo_baggins on the first day and was supported in her assertions by Anguirel.

Yeah, because on the first day, I thought that they were guilty, and on the first day, Anguirel was trying to get me killed. When the game is over, ask him yourself.

Feanor never did retract her vote from Saucepan Man that day, even though she had plenty of time to do so.

Because I still thought he was guilty.

On DAY TWO Feanor looked like she was going up the steps.

*giggle* Yeah. I'm glad you guys changed your minds... would have been awful if you'd killed an innocent (me) instead of a werewolf (Firefoot).

However, notice on that DAY Feanor couldn't resist returning to beat on poor bilbo_baggins...again.

Because I still thought he was guilty.

Feanor changed her vote as if she saw a way out of her little mess by hopping on the bandwagon.

Because I realized that even though I'm really good at keeping myself alive, I'm apparently really bad at guessing who's guilty or not.

the phantom actually built a case against Feanor which at least seemed plausible.

Plausible, yes. Accurate... pretty much. Did tp come to the wrong conclusion... heck yes he did.

Now I wonder if Feanor is really so very ignorant of what Mithalwen said.

I am. Honestly, I'd never heard the term before. Hence my pretty much entirely inaccurate guess of the meaning.

Just an implicit demand to go along.

I'm like that. Plus I was busy. Remember B-W's unceremonious killing of Mithalwen? My attempted lynching of you fits into those same guidelines.