Aragorn and Arwen: More than kissing?

[HerenIstarion]

It's merely a speculation!

Originally Posted by HerenIstarion

I acknowledge high probability of the dates being merely mixed up

See?

and if he was in a Boromir-like situation as I imagine, then he was also a major captain as well

You bring your own evil with you to Lorien. Major captain as he was, Boromir was actually sent to Imladris. Speculating, as it were, about political reasons of Arvedui serving in Gondor, I don't see barriers for him being sent away.

...Arvedui an indifferent one...

Would not bet my money on that. Circumstances being what they were, he was an unlucky one, true...