water as a symbol of good

[Lalwendë]

I disagree with this, at least in a symbolic sense. The sea is portrayed as being a tool of the Valar. Numenor deserved what it got. I don't find the sea being the means of transporting the Elves to Valinor to be particularly menacing.

I'll just explain a little of what I mean by 'menacing' in terms of the sea in Middle Earth. I do not see it as a malevolent power; its menace comes from the fact that it is tremendously powerful and has such huge potential for wreaking destruction - not unlike our own seas. The sea is in the hands of greater powers, and, right or wrong, it is up to them what they do with this power.

As to why I find the fact that the Elves are taken across it to be menacing, I am referring to the sheer size of the ocean; it is a bridge which it is almost impossible to cross, and the Elves are being borne that way. It is a one way journey with no coming back, much as the sea would have been viewed by convicts transported across the immense oceans to Australia. There is no gong back from this trip, and what is more, there is no communication, it is absolute.

[Kuruharan]

I'm afraid that I still don't agree with you, particularly as it regards the Elves. They were master mariners after all. By the time they made the voyage most of them wanted to go. It was the fulfillment of their "sea calling." I also don't think it was viewed as being anything similar to being shipped to Australia. They were going to happy land.

[Nilpaurion Felagund]

Water is Ulmo's touch. Ulmo, after all, hated the whole fad about bodies.

Also, water is the substance where the Music of Ainur has been "recorded". If you think of it this way, the drinking of water in ME involves both a physical and a spiritual act. Although the Men and Elves were created by Eru's song, not the Music, the drinking of water may be seen as a connection between the song of Eru and the song of the Ainur. Plus it sustains their life in this realm fashioned by the Music. Another connection between the two chart-topping hits.

Could the Nazgul drown? They aren't alive, I know, but they could still be defeated in a way, like in Eowyn's case. Could they have been greatly lessoned by being underwater for a time?

But then why fear fire, also? They had no flesh, so it wouldn't make sense that they would fear being burned. It just doesn't make sense. (Gurthang)

All life on ME is nourished by this water. Perhaps the Nazgûl fear the water as much as they love/hate blood: It reminds them of the life they once had.

As for fire: Well, the Flame Imperishable brought life to the Ainur and Arda (and all in it). Perhaps the Nazgûl are tortured by this reminder that they are now "cold" flame.

Or perhaps I'm reading too much into this. After all, your explanation of the otherwordly aspects of fire and water is quite a good idea.

[Elfchick7]

Also, something to consider, is that the Ring Wraiths had no true physical form. Both fire and water coulod temporarly destroy their "Physical" form. I mean, think about it, why didn't the Wraiths go after the Fellowship? I am currently of the belief that they had to sort of strengthen themselves( i.e. recuoperate ) because Sauron had not yet grown to ful power so neither had they. Just a though.